Antinuclear

Australian news, and some related international items

Australia – news this week.

News this week

November 14, 2026 Posted by | Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Ludicrous ‘festival of AUKUS’ in the west stands in dire contrast to the fiscal crisis back east

While Richard Marles and Pat Conroy are celebrating wasting billions of dollars in Perth, Jim Chalmers is being hammered for the government’s lack of fiscal discipline back east. No wonder the treasurer is ticked off.

Bernard Keane, Nov 12, 2026, https://www.crikey.com.au/2026/11/12/festival-of-aukus-perth-richard-marles-pat-conroy-waste/?utm_campaign=daily&utm_medium=email&utm_source=newsletter&_kx=63aQ1fJD0s5T2LbGRqIU-vjtNdH1KC1bpW5unf1EwZE9j4YR7qLezH_FhUZRJ4f0.WerQVn

There’s a festival of AUKUS today in Perth, and the Department of Defence is very keen for the media to know about it. It sent out a long email not once, but twice, to lucky hacks about how “Deputy Prime Minister, the Hon. Richard Marles, and Minister for Defence Industry, the Hon. Pat Conroy, will visit HMAS Stirling today”.

It was accompanied by copious notes on how to RSVP, how to receive a security pass, what footwear to don and how a hi-vis vest, hard hat and safety glasses would be supplied. And don’t be tardy:

“Following security checks, media personnel will depart for the media event via vehicle convoy, departing at 8.45am (AWST) sharp. Please note that late arrivals will not be granted access.”

For an outfit that has a policy of refusing to answer any questions in any way inconvenient, Defence’s media department sure knows how to lay on the bullshit pretty thick.

AUKUS is the climax of what has been a two-day jamboree over in Perth: yesterday was “sovereign capability” day, with Pat Conroy and a representative from the parliamentary wing of the WA fossil fuel industry, Amber Jade-Sanderson, celebrating the start of construction on the Army’s Landing Craft Heavy. Steel was cut, defence media enthused in a press release, “late last month.”


Defence loves a bit of steel cutting for boats (not to be confused with Bob Carr’s steel-cut oats) — back in September, Marles was proudly announcing that next year there would be “cutting of steel” for the first SSN AUKUS in the UK. If you’re wondering why steel will be cut in 2028 but no actual boats will arrive until **checks watch** the 2040s — at best — please direct your correspondence to media@defence.gov.au. You’re advised not to hold your breath for an answer. Let’s hope the Brits store the cut steel for AUKUS somewhere dry.

That $4 billion Landing Craft Heavy project, by the way, has been around for nearly 20 years and is — you guessed it — facing delays in its scheduled 2028 launch date. The chosen Dutch heavy landing craft design could have been built far more cheaply and quickly overseas than at a cost of half a billion dollars each in WA by scandal-plagued “sovereign” shipbuilder Austal.

Also being announced today is an $88 million program to address one of the key impediments to AUKUS, the near-total lack of a skilled workforce at a time when the US and the UK also have massive skill shortages. The program is “designed to help tradespeople transition into key roles in welding, mechanical and electrical work”, according to the reports carefully dropped by Colonel Marles’ office ahead of release. It involves funding for 275 apprentices, which is about $320,000 per worker — not quite up there with the $1 million per worker cost of some of the Albanese government’s “Future Made In Australia” handouts to multinationals, but not cheap.

It’s likely a significant understatement, because we’ll be lucky if half of those 275 actually complete the training. According to the most recent data for apprenticeship completions, four-year completions have slumped from 58% to 43% between apprentices starting in 2012 and those in 2021; the data from 2025, showing 50% of apprentices who commenced in 2021 had quit, is particularly dramatic and occurred despite Labor’s incessant talk of its commitment to apprenticeships (six-year completion rates are better — they’ve still declined, but remain above 50%).

The billions lavished on AUKUS, including handouts to the US and UK, and the upgrading of HMAS Stirling into a US nuclear submarine base, and the money wasted on our “sovereign capability” obsession, might go down well in Perth (also the lucky recipients of the appalling GST rort), but present rather ironically in the east. On the east coast, the political focus is on a federal government seemingly unwilling to rein in its historic levels of spending — or even require the Department of Defence to adhere to the same basic procurement and contract management rules that the rest of the public service has to operate by.

Who can blame Treasurer Jim Chalmers for getting the hump with his colleagues when inflation is surging but ministers are out celebrating hurling billions of taxpayer dollars into useless money pits like AUKUS or needlessly expensive local defence builds? It’s the likes of Richard Marles and Pat Conroy — the two ministers responsible for more colossal waste and poor budgeting than any others within the Albanese government — who should be under pressure over fiscal discipline, not Chalmers.

We know that defence spending blew out by more than a billion dollars in 2025-26, despite nominal growth of more than 30% already in the defence budget under the Albanese government. We still don’t have the Department of Defence’s own account of its blowout via its annual report, because the joint is so incompetent it hasn’t yet produced its 2025-26 report, weeks after the October 31 deadline.

It’s not just the abject surrender of sovereignty that offends about today’s AUKUS festival in the west; it’s the sight of a government with deeply confused priorities feigning economic responsibility as inflation soars and voters turn increasingly feral. There’s a growing Victorian Labor feel to the Albanese government — and taxpayers won’t even have some hugely expensive infrastructure to show for it, just some visits from the navy of our imperial overlords and, if things go apocalyptic, some Chinese missiles. Hang on to your hard hat and safety glasses.

Bernard Keane is Crikey’s politics editor. Before that he was Crikey’s Canberra press gallery correspondent, covering politics, national security and economics.

November 16, 2026 Posted by | politics, Western Australia | Leave a comment

SUBMISSION TO AUKUS PUBLIC INQUIRY – A submarine deal thoroughly unfair to Australia – Malcolm Turnbull.

The Pillar I submarine acquisition, as currently structured, was created by the Morrison Government and adopted by the Albanese government. It is a bipartisan error; a submarine deal that will likely result in Australia not receiving any submarines at all.

It will certainly leave Australia with long gaps in submarine capability. The AUKUS bargain is thoroughly unfair to Australia. It makes Australia even more dependent on the United States as the US is becoming, by design, a less dependable ally

No.396 The Hon. Malcolm Turnbull AC 29th Prime Minister of Australia EXTRACTS

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1cR2wrfB0Xjru0bH_DI1winCRrBoUBa9y/view

SUMMARY
I make this submission as a former Prime Minister of Australia and as a citizen with serious
concerns about the strategic consequences of the AUKUS arrangements.

I have been on the public record since AUKUS was announced by my successor in
September 2021, and have written and spoken publicly in Australia and internationally about
the risks embedded in the Pillar I submarine acquisition.

I was so concerned about the lack of public discussion and debate that I convened the
Sovereignty and Security Forum in April 2025 with a second forum held in partnership with
the University of New South Wales in March 2026. My position is consistent and well
documented. This submission draws those arguments together for this Inquiry.

I am a supporter of the alliance with the United States of America. The ANZUS Treaty and
the broader architecture of intelligence, military, and diplomatic cooperation with Washington
have been indispensable to Australian security for over seventy years. Nothing in this
submission should be read as a rejection of that alliance.

I believe Australia is a better ally to, and friend of, the United States by being self-reliant,
enhancing our sovereign capabilities and at all times telling the Americans what they need to
know, not what they want to hear.

The Pillar I submarine acquisition, as currently structured, was created by the Morrison
Government and adopted by the Albanese government. It is a bipartisan error; a submarine
deal that will likely result in Australia not receiving any submarines at all. It will certainly
leave Australia with long gaps in submarine capability. The AUKUS bargain is thoroughly
unfair to Australia. It makes Australia even more dependent on the United States as the US is
becoming, by design, a less dependable ally.

The AUKUS agreement requires that any sale by the United States of America must not
‘degrade US undersea capabilities.’ It is a contractual and legislative constraint.1 The United
States is nowhere near meeting the conditions that would allow that transfer to proceed in the
2030’s. The UK’s submarine industrial base is in absolute disarray and the delivery of
SSN-AUKUS has been acknowledged by the House of Commons as “a lengthy and complex
undertaking” the delivery of which is attendant with very great risk. The arrival of the
SSN-AUKUS boats in the early 2040s seems highly optimistic.

I also note, with regret, that this Inquiry had to be convened by civil society rather than by the
Parliament of Australia which of the three parliaments involved has had the most at stake but
been the least curious and the least informed.

I. A SUBMARINE DEAL WITH NO SUBMARINES
The stated long run goal of AUKUS is for Australia to build and operate nuclear powered
submarines in a design and construction partnership with the UK — the SSN-AUKUS. Thus
the central foundation of AUKUS was the Australian Government cancelling a shipbuilding
partnership with France so that it could be replaced by one with Britain.

The new submarine was to be based upon the as yet undesigned SSN to succeed the Royal
Navy’s current SSN, the Astute Class. The first of the new SSN-AUKUS was to be
completed in 2041. Given the impending retirement of the ageing Collins Class boats this left
a submarine capability gap in the 2030s.

The solution was for Australia to acquire three Virginia Class submarines from the United
States through the 2030s and possibly another two if the SSN-AUKUS were late (as they
inevitably would be). Australia will now receive three second-hand Block IV Virginia-class
submarines rather than the original mix of two second-hand and one new-build. This is a
material change to the programme that puts further pressure on the SSN-AUKUS component
as the life cycle of the Virginias is 33 years.

The transfer of Virginia-class boats is conditional by design, and the conditions are clearly set
out by the United States Congress and enshrined in law. Section 1352 of the National Defense
Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2024 (Public Law 118-31), signed by President Biden on 22
December 2023, authorises the President to transfer up to three Virginia-class submarines to
Australia. This transfer can only proceed upon Presidential certification to Congress, no later
than 270 days before any such transfer, that the sale will not degrade the undersea warfare
capabilities of the United States Navy, and, among other conditions, that the American
submarine industrial base has the capacity to meet the requirements of both the US Navy and
Australia. That certification is a legal precondition and cannot be waived. On current
submarine production rates, and with rising threats from adversaries, it is clear that a
President could not honestly make that certification today.

Congress made the American obligation to transfer submarines subject to these conditions in
order to protect America’s interests, not Australia’s. This conditionality is part of the deal and
represents a risk Australia, in its folly, assumed with open eyes. The United States can
comply with the AUKUS agreement and not sell any submarines to us if the President
determines that the US Navy cannot spare them. But this risk is not acknowledged by either
the Government or the Opposition in Australia. Neither of them have any plan to account for
it. The United States has been honest about the conditions. It is Australia that has not been
honest with itself.

The Congressional Research Service is a non-partisan research body of the United States
Congress, and has documented this risk since the inception of AUKUS……………………………………………………………………………………………………………..

So there is a very real risk Australia gets no Virginias at all. This risk is acknowledged
everywhere but in Canberra………………………………….

Australia should examine alternative submarine acquisition pathways as a matter of urgency,

II. AN ABDICATION OF SOVEREIGNTY

Beyond the delivery failure risk, there is a structural problem with the AUKUS Pillar I
arrangement: it represents an abdication of Australian sovereignty in matters of national
defence…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..

The United States has always been a powerful ally whose benign intent we never doubted.
But we have seen big changes with the Trump administration. The international rules based
order whose maintenance was our key strategic objective is dismissed by Washington as “a
cloud castle abstraction.”…………………………………………………………………………………………

AUKUS has diminished our sovereignty. We have effectively ceded control of a Western
Australian naval base to the US Navy. Whether we get any nuclear powered submarines will
depend on political decisions in Washington and industrial developments in the US and the
UK. It is naive to imagine that the submarines, if ever acquired, could be used other than in
accordance with American wishes.

Will AUKUS enhance our security or will it simply draw Australia into a conflict with China
whether we like it or not?

III. THE FAILURE OF PARLIAMENTARY SCRUTINY

The fact that this Inquiry has been convened by civil society rather than by the Parliament of
Australia is an indictment of our democratic institutions.

Consider what is at stake. Australia is committing hundreds of billions of dollars of public
expenditure over the coming decades. We are restructuring our naval force posture. We are
transferring strategic basing rights to allied powers without any public discussion. Our nation bears the greatest risk of any party to this arrangement. Our taxpayers carry the heaviest proportionate fiscal burden. Our sailors will crew these vessels, if they ever arrive.

There has been no comprehensive parliamentary inquiry into AUKUS Pillar I comparable in
depth or rigour to the scrutiny applied by the United States Congress or the British House of
Commons……………………… This Inquiry, whatever its formal limitations, performs a function that Parliament should have
performed. I commend those who established it and urge this Inquiry to press for full
parliamentary hearings with classified briefings made available to the relevant committees.

IV. A WEALTH TRANSFER, NOT A DEFENCE ACQUISITION

Australia has already committed approximately $3 billion to the American submarine
industrial base as a direct contribution to Virginia-class production capacity. Further billions
have been pledged to the United Kingdom. These funds are non-refundable. They are not
payments toward a specific vessel. They are capital transfers to the defence industrial bases
of our allies, with no guaranteed return in the form of an operational submarine.

Australian money channelled into the American submarine industrial base is subsidising both
the Virginia and Columbia programs simultaneously, with no assurance it benefits the one
that is supposed to deliver our boats. Australian tax payer billions poured into the UK’s
submarine industry are likewise directed at a general industrial uplift, not specifically at the
SSN-AUKUS programme. RADM Peter Briggs and others have given this Inquiry detailed
evidence on these points.

I have described AUKUS Pillar I as a massive wealth transfer from the Australian
government to the United States and the United Kingdom. The United States receives a
forward base in Western Australia, Australian capital investment in its shipbuilding industry,
Australian sailors to crew its submarines, and Australian diplomatic support, regardless of
whether a single submarine is ever transferred. The United Kingdom receives Australian
funding for an industrial base widely acknowledged to be in serious difficulty. Australia
receives, at best, the prospect of submarines in the mid-2040s and beyond.

V. THE BRITISH PILLAR: A SUBMARINE BEING DESIGNED, AN INDUSTRIAL
BASE IN DISTRESS

The problems with AUKUS Pillar I are not confined to America’s shipyards. The United
Kingdom’s contribution to this arrangement deserves equal scrutiny, and it receives almost
none from the Australian Parliament.

The SSN-AUKUS submarine that Australia is ultimately meant to operate from the early
2040s is not a vessel being built from a finished design.Following an 18-month consultation
starting in September 2021, the design was renamed SSN-AUKUS in March 2023 when
Australia joined the programme and additional US technology was incorporated. In March
2023, Vice Admiral Jonathan Mead, head of the Australian Nuclear Powered Submarine Task
Force, said the SSN-AUKUS design was “about 70 per cent mature.” A submarine design
that was 70 per cent mature in 2023, with Australia expected to take delivery of the first hull
in the early 2040s, is not a programme that invites confidence in its timeline. SSN-AUKUS is
not a product being purchased off a production line. It is a submarine being designed,
incorporating technologies from three countries, to be built simultaneously in the United
Kingdom and in Australia whose shipyards have never previously constructed a
nuclear-powered vessel……………………………………….

The nuclear reactor at the heart of SSN-AUKUS compounds those risks…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..

The state of the existing British submarine fleet tells the same story. Australia is relying on
the United Kingdom to rotate operational Astute-class submarines through HMAS Stirling as
part of the Submarine Rotational Force-West from 2027. The rationale is that Australian
submariners will gain experience operating nuclear submarines before Australia’s own boats
arrive. But the Royal Navy is in no position to spare operational submarines……………………………………………………………………………………………..

insist that Australia’sParliament be told clearly what contingency plans exist if the British industrial base cannot
deliver reactor cores on schedule; what that means for Australia’s SSN-AUKUS delivery
dates; and what Australia’s legal remedies are if the United Kingdom’s contribution to this
programme falls materially short of what was promised.

VI. BUDGET CONSIDERATIONS

The AUKUS programme expands with each budget cycle regardless of what it delivers, and
systematically crowds out the other capabilities on which Australia’s genuine near-term
defence depends…………………….

The question this Inquiry should press to answer, and which Parliament has not yet had the
resolve to ask, is how much AUKUS will cost both financially, and what is the opportunity
cost of the AUKUS programme when it comes to alternative capabilities that could keep
Australia safe?…………………………………………………………………….

VII. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

This Inquiry should record the following findings:

  1. The AUKUS Pillar I submarine delivery timeline is not credible on current evidence.
    The United States has not achieved, and is not trending toward, the production rate
    necessary to transfer Virginia-class submarines to Australia while meeting its own
    force structure requirements. The Congressional Research Service, the United States
    Navy, and Admiral Franchetti have all confirmed this publicly.
  2. The United Kingdom’s submarine industrial base faces delivery risks of the highest
    severity, as confirmed by the British Government’s own project assurance system and
    by the House of Commons Defence Committee. The Core Production Capability
    programme for reactor cores retains a Red rating. Australia’s SSN-AUKUS delivery
    timeline depends on the resolution of these British industrial difficulties, over which
    Australia has no control and limited visibility.
  3. The AUKUS arrangement as structured carries a significant risk that Australia will
    enter a period of zero submarine capability as the Collins Class retires. This would be
    the most serious failure of Australian defence planning in modern history.
  4. The terms of the AUKUS arrangement represent a meaningful reduction in Australian
    sovereignty.
  5. The absence of adequate parliamentary scrutiny of these commitments is a democratic
    failure. Parliament must institute urgent, comprehensive committee hearings with
    access to classified briefings to fulfil its constitutional responsibilities.
  6. Australia should examine alternative submarine acquisition pathways as a matter of
    urgency, including reopening discussions with France regarding the Suffren-class, to
    ensure Australia is not left defenceless in its own

November 15, 2026 Posted by | politics | Leave a comment

Submission to AUKUS Public Inquiry -We need a smart defence strategy, not the AUKUS fantasy – Merrill Stokes.

The fact that this contract requires Australia to pay a very large sum of money even if we never take possession of the Virginia class submarines seems like
something out of ‘Alice and Wonderland’ where reality has been turned on its head. That is not a contract; That is called tribute. We need to remember
Kissinger’s statement that “to be an enemy of the United States is dangerous but to be a friend is fatal”.

.No. 391 https://drive.google.com/file/d/1QYisXMY14P97uKkblGpX3wsDC4pcwPsg/view

When I first heard about AUKUS I did not believe that this was about Australia’s
defence but about US companies who produce weapons. The debt of the
United States has accumulated to 40 trillion dollars. If countries around the
world buy the weapons that American companies produce it helps their debt
problems and it ties those countries to the United States.

The fact that this contract requires Australia to pay a very large sum of money
even if we never take possession of the Virginia class submarines seems like
something out of ‘Alice and Wonderland’ where reality has been turned on its
head. That is not a contract; That is called tribute. We need to remember
Kissinger’s statement that “to be an enemy of the United States is dangerous
but to be a friend is fatal”.

I believe that it is time that Australia arrived in Asia. We do not exist next door
to the United Kingdom or the United States. We are in Asia. I think it is time we
became seriously acquainted with our neighbours, built good respectful
relationships, and developed beneficial trading arrangements. That to me is far
more likely to maintain the peace than large submarines that generate nuclear
waste.

Australia has a population of 27 million. Indonesia has a population of 287
million, China 1.4 billion, Malaysia 34 million. We are a small country that is
dry, and where all our resources need to be used and managed well. It seems
to me that investment in diplomacy would be far more profitable than
preparing for war. To afford AUKUS the tax burden needs to be increased, or we
will incur a huge debt into the foreseeable future.

We need a smart defence strategy. These submarines are already out of date.
The current technology renders these systems very vulnerable to underwater
drones and other systems that are remaking the world of war. They are much
cheaper and with radar would protect Australia much more effectively.

As has been pointed out the opportunity cost of AUKUS is productive
industries, investment in health and education, housing and other enterprises
that produce a return for human beings. Weapons only produce death and
destruction.

Australians overall are a peaceful people. Most of us would go to great lengths
to avoid war. We do not want to follow the US into any more wars of folly. It
seems as if the leaders of today are still happy to send, mostly young people, off to die for no good reason. It is time we pursued peace with as much diligence as we seem to pursue war.

The First Nations people of this country have not been consulted or considered
in this Executive decision. The parliament has not been able to launch an
inquiry into the efficacy of this decision. This offends the idea of representative
democracy. A decision this significant needs open air scrutiny.

The environmental impact of AUKUS will be considerable. Cockburn Sound is
already under stress from industry, and it plays a role in the outdoor activities
of the local community. As someone who lives in the metropolitan area of
Perth I do not want to become a target in the case of war.

3 submarines are not going to make Australia safer. These submarines will be
useful for the US if they want to wage war on China. If that were to happen, we
would be a wide-open target. Australia has been drowned in anti-China
propaganda since 1949. “China has a communist government; therefore, they
are the enemy.” That logic has never made any sense to me. When has China
indicated that invading Australia would be a good idea? It is time we looked at
the evidence instead of invoking dishonest rhetoric that has no basis in fact.

The Us has always needed enemies because since President Eisenhower’s
warning about the Military Industrial Complex the US has been the biggest
producer of weapons in the world. Every state in the Union produces weapons.
Once intrenched it is hard to replace those companies with productive
industries who will in turn produce the same level of taxes. Once the economy
is militarized it is hard to replace the guns with butter.

I fear that Australia is being enticed to go down this road. It shows a total lack
of imagination and understanding of the consequences of militarization.
Militarization requires a war because at some point we need to replace all the
weapons we just exploded. No one seems to notice that the people involved in
war suffer terrible physical, psychological and emotional damage. Ancient
buildings get blown up, animals die, the ecological damage is rarely assessed,
and it is believed that it takes five generations for the psychic damage of war to
settle.

AUKUS is simply another addition to a system that much of the world has
outgrown. The leaders of nations need to catch up and find other ways to solve
problems that must be solved through diplomacy anyway. Our energies need to
focus on Climate Change where cooperation and compromise will be essential.

November 15, 2026 Posted by | politics | Leave a comment

Submission to AUKUS Public Inquiry – Australia’s defence priorities

376. Anonymous, https://drive.google.com/file/d/13lEdBbgELBnQV54w2qV6ety7CM7Z6h7A/view

Geography as Destiny: Australia is an Island Nation
Our geographic reality dictates our strategic reality. As an island continent,
Australia faces no shared land borders. Therefore, any existential military threat to
our sovereignty must come across or from the sea. If we are talking about defence
in its truest sense—protecting our homeland from being invaded by a hostile
force—our priority must be absolute domain awareness and denial within our
immediate maritime approaches, rather than projecting force thousands of
kilometres away.


Submarines are Inherently Offensive Platforms

The current pivot toward acquiring multi-billion-dollar nuclear-powered attack
submarines (SSNs) represents a fundamental shift from home defence to
long-range power projection.

The Evidence: By definition, attack submarines are designed for forward
operations—specifically hunting enemy vessels, conducting stealth surveillance in
foreign waters, and delivering strike capabilities deep inside contested zones (such
as the South China Sea). They are optimized for concealment and long-distance
travel, not for patrolling or locking down domestic coastlines.

The Trade-off: Committing upwards of $368 billion to long-range, offensive assets
starves the budget of the practical, defensive hardware needed to guard our
actual territory.

A Strategic Pivot: Moving From the US to Regional Partners

True self-reliance means moving away from over-dependence on the United
States, a relationship that risks dragging Australia into distant conflicts that do not
serve our direct national interests. Instead, Australia should concentrate its
diplomatic and security architecture on close regional partners in the Indo-Pacific
and ASEAN. These neighbors share our immediate geographic space and have a
mutual, vested interest in regional stability, peaceful sea lanes, and
non-aggression.

Reallocating the Budget: Shore Monitoring and Intelligence

To prevent a hostile force from ever approaching our shores, defence funding
should be redirected away from offensive hulls and into robust, transparent, and
defensive technologies. We must invest heavily in:
Advanced Intelligence Networks: Enhanced cyber capabilities and signals
intelligence to read the geopolitical landscape and identify threats years before
they materialize.

Persistent Maritime Surveillance: A comprehensive network of low-cost, high-yield
uncrewed aerial vehicles (UAVs), autonomous underwater sensors, and
next-generation satellite systems to monitor our maritime borders 24/7.

Smart Sea Denial: Modern land-based anti-ship missile batteries, fixed coastal
defences, and a larger fleet of smaller, agile, conventionally powered vessels to
patrol our exclusive economic zone.

Elevating Diplomacy and Trade Over Military Might
Finally, a nation’s securest border is a friendly neighbor. Diplomatic relationships
and deep economic ties are far more effective at preventing conflict than military
deterrence.

Diplomacy First: Reinvesting a fraction of the submarine budget into foreign aid,
regional development, and diplomatic corps builds goodwill and structural
stability.

Mutual Prosperity: Strong trade relationships create interdependencies. A nation is
far less likely to become a hostile threat to a state that is an essential, reliable
trading partner. We must prioritize economic integration over military posturing.
Further Insight on the Debate

For a deeper look into the ongoing parliamentary and public opposition regarding
these exact issues, the video below outlines critical arguments raised by critics of
the AUKUS framework:
David Shoebridge on the AUKUS deal and defence priorities:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Iqd9Dd4pjvo

November 15, 2026 Posted by | politics | Leave a comment

Submission to AUKUS Public Inquiry – radioactive wastes, and the indigenous people’s experience – Mothers for a Sustainable South Australia

South Australian Traditional Owners have consistently rejected proposals for nuclear waste facilitiesbecause of their lived experience with the devastating legacy of radioactive contamination. Thehistorical trauma resulting from British nuclear weapons testing during the 1950s and 1960s—including displacement, illness and ongoing damage to Country—continues to affect communities today.

The experience of South Australia demonstrates that proposals involving nuclear waste have profound social, environmental and cultural consequences, particularly for First Nations peoples.
Past failures in consultation and the enduring impacts of nuclear activities on Traditional Owners highlight the need for a transparent, inclusive and evidence-based decision-making process

No. 374 https://drive.google.com/file/d/1YT_mYtmT8LCIXFOJQAUV3uytOL1cJzey/view

Introduction
Mothers for a Sustainable South Australia (MOSSA) is a group of South Australian mothers
concerned about the environmental and economic future of our state.

In 2016, MOSSA challenged the Nuclear Fuel Cycle Royal Commission by highlighting flaws in
the economic modelling, potential conflicts of interest relating to the proposed waste facility, and
issues of environmental racism. We stood in solidarity with First Nations communities and were
invited to address the Citizens’ Jury. Our efforts contributed to the Jury’s recommendation to reject
the proposal.

This submission focuses specifically on the high-level nuclear waste that will be generated when the
proposed nuclear-powered submarines are decommissioned. We examine the environmental and
community impacts, particularly for First Nations peoples. We believe the risks associated with the
management of AUKUS nuclear submarine waste alone mean that AUKUS should be opposed,
because no safe long-term proposal for the generated nuclear waste exists

Managing High-Level Nuclear Waste Managing High-Level Nuclear Waste
The waste generated by nuclear-powered submarines is weapons-grade radioactive material. As we
highlighted in our submission to the South Australian Nuclear Fuel Cycle Royal Commission in
2016:
It is necessary that high-level nuclear waste is kept secure, and safe, for over one hundred thousand
years.
No one can predict how weapons, security threats and geopolitical risks will evolve over the next 40
or 100 years, let alone over many centuries. We can, however, be confident that, based on the
changes witnessed over the past 200 years, the nature of warfare, terrorism and security risks will
continue to evolve dramatically in the decades ahead.

For an AUKUS capacity, Australia will need to have a high-level nuclear waste facility operational
by approximately the 2050s—or potentially earlier, depending on the age of the second-hand
nuclear submarines purchased from the United States.

At present, there is no operational permanent disposal facility anywhere in the world for high-level
radioactive waste. Finland is close to opening the Onkalo deep geological repository. The site
selection process began in 1983, more than 40 years ago. It has reportedly cost approximately £1
billion to construct and is expected to require a further £4 billion to operate until it is filled, sealed
and closed around 100 years after opening. This represents a total cost of approximately £5 billion
(around AUD $9.5 billion) before the facility is permanently sealed.

From that point onwards, what will be the ongoing costs of ensuring the waste remains safely
contained for the thousands of years during which it remains hazardous? How will it be protected
from terrorism or future military threats? As Ian Lowe wrote recently in the InDaily, nobody knows what the cost of securely storing the nuclear waste from decommissioned nuclear powered
submarines will be, but based on costings from the South Australian Nuclear Royal commission, it
could be around $190B, half as much again as the budget for the submarines.


Both the United Kingdom and the United States have decommissioned nuclear-powered submarines
without a clear long-term solution for managing their highly radioactive waste. We believe it is
reasonable to conclude that Australia is unlikely to have a permanent high-level waste repository
ready by the 2050s. This raises important questions about where this waste will be stored in the
interim and how the associated environmental, security and public safety risks will be managed.

Our additional concerns regarding the management of weapons-grade nuclear waste include:

  • How will the waste be safely removed from the submarines?
  • How will it be transported safely, and securely, from ports to an interim or permanent
    storage facility?
  • How can Australia guarantee that this waste will not become a military or terrorist target at
    any stage from the Port facilities to the long term repository?
  • Do we have an assurance that Australia will not become the repository for other nations’
    weapon grade submarine nuclear waste? If so, how will that assurance be maintained across
    hundreds to thousands of years of government change?

Community Impacts, Especially for First Nations Peoples
South Australia provides clear examples of the impacts that proposals for high-level nuclear waste
facilities can have on communities and First Nations peoples.

In 2016, the South Australian Government established a Royal Commission to investigate whether
the state should accept high-level nuclear waste from overseas as a commercial enterprise. The
proposal was promoted as having the potential to generate more than $100 billion for the state.

Strong public opposition led then Premier Jay Weatherill to establish a Citizens’ Jury to determine
whether the proposal should proceed.

The Jury ultimately rejected the proposal, citing a lack of trust in governments’ ability to manage the
facility over many generations, the enormous safety risks associated with waste that remains
hazardous for thousands of years, and the absence of any fully operational deep geological
repository anywhere in the world that could serve as a proven model.

These concerns remain equally relevant to the management of high-level waste generated by
Australia’s future nuclear-powered submarines.

The complete absence of meaningful community consultation regarding Australia’s entry into the
AUKUS agreement is also deeply concerning, and is one of the reasons for this inquiry. Many
members of the community feel powerless, alienated and angry by the lack of transparency
surrounding such a significant and locked in costly national commitment.

South Australian Traditional Owners have consistently rejected proposals for nuclear waste facilities
because of their lived experience with the devastating legacy of radioactive contamination. The
historical trauma resulting from British nuclear weapons testing during the 1950s and 1960s—including displacement, illness and ongoing damage to Country—continues to affect communities today.

Concerns about threats to groundwater, sacred sites and continued access to traditional lands remain
central to First Nations opposition to nuclear waste storage.

Traditional Owners also have a long history of being excluded from decisions affecting their lands.
A recent example occurred in South Australia in 2023, when the Federal Court ruled in favour of the
Barngarla people after finding that the process used to select Napandee, near Kimba, as the site for
Australia’s proposed low-level radioactive waste facility was affected by apprehended bias and
inadequate consultation.

While the Australian Government has stated that high-level waste from decommissioned submarine
reactors will ultimately be stored on dedicated defence land, the Australian Naval Nuclear Power
Safety legislation passed in October 2024 provides the Government with broad powers to determine
what constitutes a suitable site.

We believe First Nations peoples remain in a compromised position regarding consultation over the
location of both permanent and interim storage facilities. Given Australia’s history of inadequate
consultation on nuclear issues, it is essential that any future decisions are made transparently,
respectfully and with the free, prior and informed consent of affected Traditional Owners.

Conclusion
Australia is embarking on a project that will create highly radioactive, weapons-grade nuclear wasterequiring secure management for more than 100,000 years. Yet there is currently no publicly-available clear plan outlining where this waste will be stored, how it will be transported, howinterim storage will be managed, or how future environmental and security risks will be addressed.

The experience of South Australia demonstrates that proposals involving nuclear waste have
profound social, environmental and cultural consequences, particularly for First Nations peoples.
Past failures in consultation and the enduring impacts of nuclear activities on Traditional Owners
highlight the need for a transparent, inclusive and evidence-based decision-making process
.

We urge the Committee to recommend AUKUS be opposed given the absence of:

  • a comprehensive, publicly available strategy for the long-term management of high-level
    nuclear waste;
  • independent assessments of the environmental, security and financial risks associated with
    transporting, storing and disposing of the waste;
  • meaningful consultation with affected communities and First Nations peoples, consistent
    with the principles of free, prior and informed consent;
  • transparent public scrutiny and parliamentary oversight of interim or permanent waste
    storage locations.

Given the extraordinary timescales, costs and risks associated with managing this waste, these
issues cannot be treated as matters for future governments to resolve. They require clear answers,robust planning and genuine public engagement before Australia accepts responsibility for creating this legacy

Mothers for a Sustainable South Australia

  • Maureen Graney
  • Mary Houlahan
  • Tracey Kermond
  • Michelle Parsons
  • Barbara Pocock

November 15, 2026 Posted by | politics | Leave a comment

Submission to AUKUS Public Inquiry – it’s not about submarines, it’s about a bonanza of tax-payer money to USA – Terry McBride

No 324 Extracts

Aukus is not about submarines or Australian security or defence. It a about a bonanza in free money (Tax payer
money) which will be borrowed from the US. For the people in the know its not raining money its pouring money.

Will AUKUS keep us safe? NO .. at what cost? It will far greater than 368B and will last for thousands of years.

These nuclear-powered hunter-killer submarines (SSNs) are massive “apex predators” built for deep-ocean
operations, high-speed transit, and long-range force projection. Lowy Institute. The SSN-AUKUS submarines
(and the stopgap Virginia-class vessels) are not specifically designed for shallow, confined waters like the
archipelagos of Australia’s north. “the Australian Naval Institute. In other words they are for making war away
from Australia and not making Australia safe and not for Australian defence but for Australian s War
department.

You had better be careful

Rex Patrick report on 6 Aug 2025 under FOI. The Australian Federal Police has quietly created a new unit called AUKUS Command. Which has a mandate which extends beyond just submarines. It also includes public order management and that will be used to monitor and respond to political opposition and protest activity linked to a rapidly expanding US military in Australia. This story would never seen the light of day without Rex Patrick because it was launched in secret. West Media Report. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HverWMzaiGY this unit has been setup to protect MIC business interests not protect Australians.

20 Feb 2025. The Australian Naval Institute
China’s new magnetic wake detection technology mark the end of stealth submarine warfare? Researchers at
Northwestern Polytechnical University (NPU) in Xian, China, have unveiled a novel detection method capable ofidentifying even the stealthiest submarines by tracking their magnetic wakes. The team, led by Associate
Professor Wang Honglei, discovered that the magnetic fields generated by the wakes of submarines, can be
detected using airborne magnetometers at any depth. This has now been adapted to underwater listening
stations that are deployed though out south china sea.

US Naval News: China leads the US in the specific field of Extra-Large Unmanned Underwater Vehicles
(XLUUVs). Beijing has deployed massive drone submarines—some up to 45 meters long with an estimated
10,000 nautical mile range—that rival crewed submarines.

What does this mean: Our crews are dead as soon as they leave port. 114 dead, 368 Billion down the toilet
and radioactive waste leaking into the ocean in the time it takes a politician to avoid a question or tell a
lie.

How did we get here.
Unfortunately as with everything government nothing is as it seems. Lobbyist were able to zero in on people in
the government 2021 of low morality, weak character, giant egos and deeply corrupt. People like this are easily
manipulated by people much smarter and motivated by the potential pay day in the multi millions of dollars.

Asio and Australian Defence Department and its public servants have far to close a relationship with the
Privately owned Military Industrial Complex (MIC), MIC Lobbyist who were former soldiers, intel, politicians, MI6 and CIA. All these agencies have a huge interest in manipulating weak minded ADO and APS. The owners of these people (Military Industrial Complex and bankers) are very smart, long-term planners, master manipulators and deceivers.

We had to prove ourselves. The USA did not want to hand over secret US tech and system to a minor player. So they want us prove we could be trusted. A group of US psychopaths ordered Australia to arrest Mr Dan Duggan against Australian law and hold him illegally so far 3.6 years in MS without trial or braking Australia law to prove our loyalty. If he has broken a law bail him and let him have his day in open court. This is the type of people we want to partner with? What happened to us?

Aukus is not just about submarines. Its about nuclear waste, Nuclear sub decommissioning, Continuous war,
Australian yellow cake industry, Domestic Nuclear energy through the back door, Changing State and Federal
legislation around uranium mining and nuclear energy power plants, giving over Billions to unprofitable and
deeply corrupt US and UK ship building yards, Creating a Debt Trap for Australia and its States to a failing USA empire. It will also Economical Trap Australian state govs in weapons of mass destruction production through debt and employment the same way it has done in most American states. The MIC wields massive control over US states.

Aukus is not about submarines or Australian security or defence. It a about a bonanza in free money (Tax payer
money) which will be borrowed from the US. For the people in the know its not raining money its pouring money.
If you watch the courts you can see what men will do for a few hundred dollars. Now imagine what they will do for Billions of dollars of free unaccountable money. Ie were the 10B already gone?

Executive Power (Section 61): Under Section 61 of the Australian Constitution, the executive power of the
Commonwealth is vested in the Crown and is exercisable by the Prime Minister and Cabinet. This gives the
executive the sole authority to conduct foreign affairs, negotiate treaties, and enter into international
security agreements without requiring prior parliamentary debate or approval. [1]

Section 61 means we can’t send the 2021 government to jail for the rest of their lives. Here’s the first legislation amendment to section 61. No government or its agents can negotiate foreign affairs, negotiate treaties, enter into international security agreements or procurement without requiring prior parliamentary debate then get approval for any amounts of over 1 Billion Australian dollars.

So how has the ADO and APS and politicians handled previous procurement for the Defence Dept?

  • MRH-90 Taipan Helicopters: Withdrawn from service early due to ongoing maintenance,
    safety, and supply chain issues, making it one of the most prominent capability shortfalls.
  • Redback Infantry Fighting Vehicle (LAND 400 Phase 3): Flagged in an ANAO Report by
    Bernard Keane . The project missed key milestones, suffered from huge costs, and
    highlighted the ADF’s tendency to mandate complex, bespoke integrations rather than
    simply buying military kit “off the shelf”.
  • Hunter Class Frigates: Programs consistently flagged by defence experts as being
    severely behind schedule and well over their initial budget. Ranked among the most expensive
    and delayed naval programs, with costs reaching $9 billion per ship. Deliveries have stretched out,
    and critics have argued the ships will be lightly armed and overmatched when they finally enter
    service
  • myClearance: An IT system procurement that was strongly criticized by auditors for
    bypassing procurement rules and failing to manage risk during the tender process.
  • Evolved Cape Class Patrol Boats: Programs audited over various administrative failures
    and supply chain issues.
  • Joint Strike Fighters (F-35s): Faced widespread global and domestic scrutiny over
    decade-long delays and multi-billion dollar cost blowouts throughout their acquisition
    timeline.

Seasprite Helicopters: Acquired second-hand in a $1 billion program, these Vietnam War-era airframes
suffered severe software issues and were ultimately scrapped without ever entering active operational service.

Battle Management System: The ADF binned a $1.3 billion digital battle management system supplied by
Elbit Systems after a decade of delays, cost blowouts, and rumoured security and data-exposure concerns,
shifting to an interim fix instead

Bushranger utility vehicle the army is attempting to build. The prototypes were 10
times less reliable than the army thought acceptable. But the army took the vehicle
anyway because the only other vehicle trialled was twice as bad again.

Australia’s worst buy in military hardware might be the Anzac-class frigates. The last
frigate will be completed 15 years after the first, so all the communications equipment
bought at the beginning is now out of date………………………………………………………………………

add in the 5 Billion dollars we had to pay the French to get out of that sub deal with France…………….

To assess if the AUKUS nuclear-powered attack submarines will keep Australians more secure.
No IT WILL NOT. We now know for sure we are a nuclear strike target now just because we have them.

To explore the implications of Australia acquiring nuclear-powered submarines for regional
peace and security.

Asian countries have been watching Australia closely now since Oct 2023. When it was our chance to stand up
for international law, Humanitarian law, Rome Statute, UN, treaties, conventions we have signed on to and
common human decency. We failed on all levels. We showed Asian countries we have no respect for the rule of
law, don’t honour what we sign on to and complete disdain for a rules based order………………………………………..

Aukus will create a regional arms race which will suit the MIC and bankers down to the ground…………………………………

Do you really think they have not noticed we are building 4 multi billion dollar weapons of mass destruction
factories in 4 different states for the MIC? The Australian Government is investing in multiple defence manufacturing hubs across the nation to produce precision missiles, rocket motors, and large-
calibre artillery projectiles. This builds on the Australian Guided Weapons and Explosive Ordnance Plan and is backed by a major funding injection.

These strategic munitions and weapons manufacturing facilities include:

  • South Australia (Port Wakefield & Adelaide): A new Lockheed Martin facility at Port
    Wakefield was opened for the production of Guided Multiple Launch Rocket System
    (GMLRS) missiles. Additionally, South Australia is central to a wider $30 billion shipyard
    program.
  • New South Wales (Newcastle & Mulwala): An $850 million Kongsberg facility in
    Williamtown near Newcastle is scheduled to manufacture the Naval Strike Missile.
    Upgrades and dedicated solid rocket motor complexes are also underway at the Mulwala
    munitions facility.
  • Queensland (Maryborough): Through a $72 million contract, the government is partnering
    with Rheinmetall NIOA Munitions to establish an advanced forging facility for large-caliber
    155mm M795 artillery projectiles.
  • Western Australia (Collie/Perth): The Western Australian government is seeking
    expressions of interest to build a third domestic weapons manufacturing hub in the state,
    with the mining town of Collie flagged as a potential site.

Yep no money for schools, hospitals and public education but always money for the foreign, privately owned
MIC, Bankers, Oil exce and other low lifes.

To assess the economic, technological, and employment effects of AUKUS-related initiatives,
and their overall impact on the ADF’s preparedness and force structure.

Yes there will be employment but who wants to tell their children you spend all day making bombs to kill brown people’s children

Yes some Australians will have to train up to a very high standard which nuclear physics, engineering and
specialty manufacturing courses will have to be introduced to train them but you cant justify the cost of this
education unless you build nuclear power stations. Bang there’s the back door blowing open. Which of course
means more uranium mining. Bang there blows open another back door.


The Uranium Mining and Nuclear Facilities (Prohibitions) Repeal Bill 2025
passed the New South
Wales Legislative Council (the upper house) on May 7, 2026.
The bill was officially transmitted to the Legislative Assembly (the lower house) for concurrence on
May 27, 2026. It requires passage in the lower house and royal assent to become law……………………..

Despite Australians overwhelming voting against uranium mining and nuclear power stations at the last federal
election NSW Libertarian John Ruddick has tried to go against the wishes of the people.

Federal Coalition’s aggressive push for nuclear power, several other Australian states are actively fighting over
their respective bans/laws.

9 June 2026, the WA Liberal-National Coalition officially committed to lifting the uranium mining ban if
they win government. Backed heavily by the Chamber of Minerals and Energy (CME) and mining unions………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

Safety Concerns: As a strong advocate for submariner safety, Rex Patrick
publicly raised serious concerns when the RAN canceled pressurised escape
training for crews Veteran warns Australia’s Class submarine fleet has …. He
stated this decision exposed crews and deprived their families of the comfort of
knowing there is a reliable rescue system in place in the event of an emergency…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

What is the likelihood of AUKUS submarines being delivered on time and on budget?

NONE

Can AUKUS nuclear accidents in port or Australian waters be absolutely averted or contained, can
nuclear waste be stored safely, and what are the environmental and community impacts, especially
for First Nations peoples?………………………………………………………………..

Nuclear Waste

………………………………………………………………AUKUS was always about 2 things. Starting a war with China under an Australian flag so we get hit first for the
USA. But mainly about taking US and UK nuclear waste. Their Nuclear disassembly of their retired Nuke Subs is
nothing short of atrocious and their totally irresponsible handling of their own Nuclear waste is appalling. They
don’t want to pay for it themselves and look after it for 10,000 years. They need a sucker to take it and pay for it
for 10,000 years. They need weak minded politicians and equally weak minded population and Australia is full
of them.

………………………………………………………………………………………4. International Expansion Anxieties

AUKUS Proliferation Fears: Under the AUKUS agreement, the US and UK will assist Australia in
managing its own nuclear submarine waste. Critics and international observers argue that neither the
US nor the UK has successfully solved their own high-level waste problems, viewing the arrangement as
an unacceptable exportation of hazardous environmental and political burdens for 10,000 years.

Disposing of a U.S. nuclear submarine costs about $60million per hull. This process takes several years per
submarine. However the storage of waste lasts 10,000 years. Thats about 5 million per year after storage is
built. (10B) That’s about 50Billion plus interest plus GST………………………………………………………………….

Long-Term Cancers

DNA damage from radiation can result in gene mutations that eventually lead to cancer, sometimes appearing
decades after exposure. Commonly linked cancers include:

  • Leukemia: Specifically, most forms of leukemia except chronic lymphocytic leukemia.
  • Thyroid Cancer: Often caused by the accumulation of radioactive iodine (e.g., from nuclear fallout).
  • Lung Cancer: Can be caused by inhaling radioactive dust or gases, such as radon.
  • Other Cancers: Includes multiple myeloma, mesothelioma, non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, and cancers of
    the bone, breast, stomach, and colon.

Chronic and Systemic Diseases
Prolonged exposure or internal contamination through breathing or ingestion can also cause non-cancerous
systemic diseases. These include:

  • Cardiovascular disease: Elevated risks of circulatory disorders.
  • Cataracts: Damage to the eyes resulting in clouded vision.
  • Birth defects and developmental anomalies: Damage to fetuses and hereditary genetic alterations

Are there cost-effective and achievable alternatives to AUKUS that better enhance Australia’s peace
and security?

Make love not war. Become friends with our pacific and Asian neighbours. Stop trying to act like a stand over
man for the USA. It does not work look at the middle east now in 2026.

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. As for Australia it’s a who has the biggest dick contest. The ADO just wants to parade around going we have
nuclear subs and you don’t, so don’t mess with us. Its to intimidate SE Asian into compliance so we can
continue to stealing from them. But the idiots in charge are in denial that these countries are joining BRIC’s for afair deal. These countries are now about to beat us on every metric like China has.

They are in this is who we trust? What happened to us?

Recommendations

  1. Run a massive social media campaign aimed at people 16 to 40 not to join any branch of the military. Our
    leaders have shown they have no moral compass, genocide supporters and let themselves be controlled by a
    foreign nations and lobbyist, have contempt for the Australian people and are fascists. Who wants to go and die
    for MIC exces, Oil exces, Arms dealers, psychotic leaders of foreign nations, for psychotic Australia politicians
    and be ordered to commit war crimes. So you can spend the rest of your life in depression and jail.
  2. 2. Scrap AUKUS immediately. Pay no money to the US or UK……………………………………………………………….https://drive.google.com/file/d/1A_qcVBK58ZvgWvSzp3dC5Sao03IvZj3u/view

November 15, 2026 Posted by | politics | Leave a comment

Submission to AUKUS Public Inquiry – with a focus on Western Australia – STOP AUKUS

No 320 https://drive.google.com/file/d/1nkcNWsxkD82ipTDEguemqIQ0LNEk0DXn/view

Stop AUKUS WA is grateful for the opportunity to make a submission to the 2026 Public
Inquiry into AUKUS.
Although not specifically included in the TOR of the Inquiry, we will mainly focus on the
regional/local impacts of AUKUS and only briefly outline our perception of the broader
issues, noting that we concur with the substantial submissions to date by respected experts
including Tilman Ruff, Richard Tanter, Dave Sweeney, Joseph Camileri and John Lander.
National and International Issues

An appropriate defence asset?
The Virginia class submarines to be purchased under AUKUS Pillar 1 were originally
designed for the main purpose of deterring Chinese submarines from launching missiles
into mainland USA.

They are not suitable for defence of coastal Australia where a larger fleet of smallersubmarines would be more appropriate. By the time of delivery of Virginia class or SNN-AUKUS submarines they are likely to be obsolete due to improved underwater detection methods and development of underwater drones (ironically being developed under AUKUSPillar 2).

Financial implications

The huge cost of procuring nuclear-powered submarines under AUKUS, now estimated at
A$375 billion (albeit including a substantial contingency), inevitably detracts from
expenditure on other ADF options. This in turn exacerbates the defence budget creep which
consumes funds better spent on combating real existential threats of climate change and
nuclear war, and on social well-being programs. Furthermore, history has shown that initial
projected costs of large military or civilian projects (e.g. Snowy Hydro) inevitably blow out.
The risks of committing to such expenditure are huge – non-delivery of submarines, pending
obsolescence, the fallacious assumption China is our enemy etc.

Loss of sovereignty

The military interoperability and increased implementation of the Force Posture Agreement
(FPA) implicit in AUKUS will ensure further subservience to the USA, obliging Australia to
continue following the US into wars of its choosing. The assumption that subservience to the
US or having US bases on our soil will ensure Australia’s security and safety is false
particularly in light of the prevailing “America First” agenda. The recent attacks on US Bases
in West Asia are also testimony to this.

There are also serious doubts Australia would have the nuclear-ready workforce to operate
its own nuclear-powered submarines; equally that the US will meet the production level
requirements needed to provide Australia with the much touted 3 Virginia Class SSNs in
2032, ’35, ‘38 and that the US will simply perpetuate a quasi SRF-West co-crewed by US
and Australian crews but under the command of the US.

Abrogating treaties
AUKUS also threatens to undermine the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NNPT) to which
Australia is a signatory: it would exploit the loophole in the Treaty which technically permits
visiting vessels (as opposed to ‘stationed’ vessels) being nuclear capable. This is especially
alarming given Australia’s “Don’t ask – Don’t tell’ attitude and the increasing likelihood that
the future models of Virginia Class submarines could be nuclear armed.

Further, the highly enriched uranium (HEU) used in Virginia Class submarines, and in the
Rolls Royce reactors for Australia’s SSN-AUKUS to be built at Osborne, can be used either
directly or with reprocessing, in the manufacture of nuclear weapons. Although the current
legislation prohibits Australia from enacting this, there is always the implied risk or possible
breach of security which could facilitate this.

Nuclear Waste Concerns (other than localised at HMAS Stirling)
AUKUS commits Australia to storing the high level nuclear waste from the 2nd hand Virginia
Class submarines to be procured in the 2030’s and Australia’s own SSN-AUKUS.

Decommissioning the reactors will generate potent waste remaining dangerously radioactive
for tens of thousands of years. This will require secure storage at an undisclosed
astronomical price and ‘defence site’ yet to be determined – no doubt to be again rightfully
challenged by First Nations peoples. AUKUS would be committing Australia to an inevitable
problem to which no solution is on the horizon, a damming legacy.

Diplomacy vs aggressive deterrence

China is Australia’s major trading partner as well as the intended US target adversary of
AUKUS which inevitably could have adverse repercussions on trade relations. Some harsh
trade restrictions imposed by China recently suggest that this is already happening. Further,
most Asian nations see AUKUS as an anglospheric reincarnation of European colonial
dominance – the antithesis of enhanced regional security.

Australia’s security could best be enhanced by rapidly expanding Australian diplomacy in the
region, combined with an independent foreign policy based on peace and justice.

Impacts of AUKUS on research, universities and foreign student intake

AUKUS imposes laborious and stringent restrictions on research partnerships and foreign
students from countries other than the USA and UK. This is reportedly leading to a brain drain back to China or to elsewhere. Recent data cited by Clarivate reveals Australia-
Chinese co-authored publications in the top 10% of those most cited globally over the pastfive years in computer science, materials science and engineering far outnumbers those co-
authored with US partners – 54% to 12%. Only 5% of China’s top publications involve an Australian author.


Confining Australia to research and development with its anglosaxon partners is a setback to
our scientific and technological development which risks Australia being left way behind in
the global arena. It is also having a negative impact on the foreign student intake which in
turn impacts universities’ income earning capacity.

WA Specific Issues

Loss of local jurisdiction

Currently, two bays in the north of Garden Island and beaches on the west of the island are
accessible to the public by boat during daylight hours for recreational purposes. There is
also a “closed naval waters” buffer zone to the east of the island in Cockburn Sound.
Although the Australian Navy, the Australian Submarine Agency (ASA) and the Australian
Naval Nuclear Power Submarine Agency (ANNPSA) all claim that public access to the island
will not be further impacted under Submarine Rotational Force West (SRF-West) as of 2027,
it is difficult to believe. The whole of the island is already a designated [nuclear] zone under
the ANNPS Act.

Also, a considerable area of Cockburn Sound adjacent to Garden Island, now accessible to
recreational boats, would likely become a restricted zone. With the increased traffic and
stationing of nuclear-powered submarines and the radioactive waste facility to be built in the
southern part of the island it is also highly likely that the current assurances that public
access to the Sound for fishing, boating, snorkelling and other water activities will not be
impacted, will ultimately prove untrue.

2. Environmental heritage effects………………………………….

3. Housing, employment and the local economy………………………………….

4. Henderson Defence Precinct – the AUKUS dry dock……………………………….

  1. Congestion in Cockburn Sound: commercial shipping, toxic industry and
    recreational boating

6. Local Nuclear Issues – Waste and Radioactivity

The stationing of US and UK nuclear powered submarines at Stirling under SRF-West
necessitates in-water maintenance which in turn requires a Controlled Industrial Facility
(CIF) to manage and store the low level radioactive waste. ARPANSA granted the
construction licence to ASA in 2025 after a flawed public consultation – the public were
denied access to requested technical and detailed information regarding the intended
structure and radioactive materials to be handled and ultimate disposal procedures.

No information was given of the identity and amounts of the actual isotopes involved, other
than to claim that it would be “low level waste” of the type emanating from hospitals and
research labs such as gloves and protective clothing. It is essential to know the details of
hazardous substances before it can be worked out how best to handle and store them. The
radioactive waste was initially claimed to be of short half-life but later it was admitted that
some isotopes would have a half-life of about 300 years. The actual lifespan of the CIF (on
precarious geological island land, especially given climate change) was put at 40-50 years.
And all in the face of there still not being a permanent/long term storage site/plan or in fact
anywhere to take it to in case of emergency.

It is feared that the radiological waste from the temporary CIF storage facilities at Stirling and
Henderson will eventually be transported by road through, or in close proximity to, populated
areas. Authorities prefer not to discuss this and claim it is still in the planning stage.

At other bases for UK and US nuclear powered submarines there have been reports of
release of radioactive materials into the air and the harbour (e.g. Faslane, Scotland). In the
AUKUS proposals so far put out for consultation such possible emissions (including
evaporation of liquid waste) have been acknowledged but with no clear indication as to how
they would be monitored, minimized, remedied or reported to the public.

7. Accidents, safety and secrecy

…………………….Disturbingly, we have learned that the US is intending to relax its safety standards for
radiation exposure by a factor of five, against long accumulated medical advice. It remains
unknown as to what extent these relaxed standards would be applied in and around US
nuclear powered submarines, especially as the SRF West rotations will occur under the
2014 Force Posture Agreement (FPA) with the US and Stirling being listed as a special
facility and area under the FPA. Under Article IV.1, this gives the US “unimpeded access to
and use of Stirling” for related activities.

Article V.5 states “The Parties shall mutually develop procedures to address incident and
accident responses, including for the following matters: (a) first response; (b) the security of
incident or accident sites and human remains; (c) investigations; and (d) public statements
concerning accidents and incidents.”

Stop AUKUS has sought clarification of this issue via Questions posed at the various ASA
Information sessions held in 2025 and 2026 in Fremantle, Perth, Cockburn and Rockingham
and via repeated emails to the ASA – all to no avail.

The nuclear safety record for nuclear submarines is not good, and unlikely to be better for a
nation with no prior experience in nuclear submarines. At least nine nuclear-powered
submarines have sunk. Decommissioned nuclear-powered submarines are not dismantled
due to absence of permanent storage facilities for their reactor fuel, anywhere. Since 2006 a
total of 789 nuclear safety events were recorded at HM Naval Base Clyde at Faslane and
nearby Royal Naval Armaments Depot Coulport. The UK has ceased public reporting of
nuclear accidents since 2017.

With the standing up of the Australian Naval Nuclear Power Safety Agency (ANNPSA) on 1
November 2025 it has taken over naval nuclear safety and reporting from ARPANSA. It
reports to the Minister of Defence, who would no doubt be hesitant to disclose any mishaps
or misdeeds of their ministry – thus is an ineffective mechanism to gain and maintain social
licence of AUKUS, especially in the advent of any accidents.

It is usual practice that the military everywhere, and most civilian governments, are reluctant
to publicly report accidents, and especially those involving radiation, to prevent credibility
loss and loss of social licence. This tendency towards secrecy is readily apparent in the
ongoing local AUKUS public consultancy process (e.g. “information not available for security
reasons”) and ASA’s community information sessions in a belated attempt to gain some
semblance of social licence which is clearly lacking in the ill-conceived AUKUS plan.

Although visiting nuclear powered submarines fall under the OPSMAN visiting ships manual,
the new Regulator will play a role – seemingly yet to be defined even though the Regulator
has been in existence for 8 months. The WA Police are responsible for managing any
incident response under the HAZMAT Annex A – Radiation Escape From A Nuclear Powered
Warship (NPW) – State Hazard Plan. An update of the 2023 manual to factor in the ANNPSA
has been in the making for some time and still uncompleted or if it has been it is still not
publicly available.

We maintain none of the above bides well for social licence nor Australia’s nuclear readiness
in the eyes of its AUKUS partners.

8 Target
Our initial protests that establishing a base for US nuclear submarines in the vicinity of the
Perth metropolitan area would make us a prime target, rather than protect us, in any future
global-scale conflict were essentially dismissed. However, the recent US-Israel war on Iran
has illustrated how US bases do become prime, first-choice targets. The bombing of Pearl
Harbour by the Japanese in their opening of the war with the USA some 85 years ago
provides another example.

There are no contingency provisions for the public in the event of attacks on HMAS Stirling,
either conventional or nuclear. A successful conventional attack would in any case lead to
the uncontrolled release of radioactive contents from submarines and storage facilities.

9 China trade
A majority of the container ships visiting Fremantle, and eventually Westport, are involved in
the China trade. The existence of AUKUS discourages that trade with the general
understanding that the purpose of AUKUS is to join the US in militarily confronting, or as a
minimum, containing China. Understandably China is now seeking alternative trading
partners and would be reluctant to send their commercial shipping into hostile ports.

Conclusion
It is apparent that creation of AUKUS was primarily motivated by Australian political party
jostling for power, the US desire for a nuclear submarine base in the Indian Ocean/Australia
and the lingering nostalgia of the UK for a lost empire. The project as proposed is more likely
to antagonise Australia’s relations with its neighbours rather than enhance the security of the
country, and we would inevitably need to sacrifice further sovereignty to the USA. AUKUS
has so far not received the required parliamentary scrutiny for such a complex, costly and
future setting commitment.

Public consultancies held around various components of AUKUS such as the Australian
Submarine Agency’s licence applications for the siting and construction of a radioactive
waste storage facility at Stirling lacked sufficient information for thorough public scrutiny and
the outcome seemed preordained.

In WA, promises of increased employment and economic stimulation seem exaggerated,
especially when all of the disadvantages of proceeding are considered. It is clear that the
issue of nuclear waste has not been adequately thought through, especially the long-term
storage aspects designed to deal with nuclear reactor isotopes for millennia.

AUKUS poses a public health and safety, environmental, security and social cohesion risk to
the Cockburn Sound communities. It lacks social licence and a cost benefit analysis.

Australia’s submarine and defence policy needs an urgent rethink – as does the Australia-US
Alliance.

November 15, 2026 Posted by | politics | Leave a comment

Submission to AUKUS Public Inquiry – Scrap AUKUS – Teachers Federation

No 309

Maxine Sharkey, General Secretary, AEU NSW Teachers Federation

31 July 2026

Extracts – ” ……………………… The AUKUS announcement in September 2021, made clear that once again the peace movement, including Federation, would be required to mobilise against the warmongers who seek to line the pockets of the vested interests in the global weapons manufacturing industry, at the expense of government spending on education and other social services and investment in mitigations and solutions to the real threat – the climate emergency.

Costs
The massive $368 billion expenditure on nuclear-powered submarines that may or maynot be able to be delivered and may or may not utilise obsolete technology when they are, is unacceptable and will affect generations to come as those costs are inevitably diverted from vital public services…………………………………….

While the Albanese government asserts that there will be jobs created by the AUKUS
deal, there has not been any credible evidence presented that this is the case,
particularly when compared to the number of jobs that would be created without AUKUS, – in education, health, and manufacturing, for example, not to mention those jobs that would be lost if a nuclear submarine base is imposed on a functioning port and the industries that use it………………

Loss of independence
From the outset, Federation held concerns that the AUKUS pact would compromise
Australia’s ability to pursue an independent foreign policy, in particular, the prospect of hosting of US military forces on Australian territory. The risks that Australia will be dragged into future foreign conflicts and wars has only intensified under the current US administration.

It is not clear how AUKUS will allow Australia to engage in diplomacy in our region, and not merely follow our AUKUS “partners”, particularly the US, into their wars.

Secrecy
The lack of transparency about the details of the AUKUS deal is ongoing and highly
concerning for members of the community including teachers, as affected workers, as well as their students and families………………………………..


For example, the location of the proposed East Coast base for the submarines remains
secret. Port Kembla and Newcastle, both towns with significant population of Federation
members, have been mooted, with documents released by an order for the production
of documents in the NSW parliament indicating that Port Kembla was the preferred site

There has been no transparency from the Australian government around the question of
how high-level nuclear waste and the use of weapons-grade uranium will be managed.
Historically, the Australian government has repeatedly tried to set up nuclear waste
dumps on First Nations lands. The AUKUS deal will only intensify that pressure.

The Albanese government states that: “Australia will manage all radioactive waste
generated by its own Virginia Class and SSN-AUKUS submarines, including radioactive
waste generated through operations, maintenance and decommissioning.


All waste, including spent fuel, will be managed safely, informed by international best
practice and in accordance with Australia’s international and domestic legal obligations
and commitments.”6

But to date there has been no detail provided about how the above will be achieved.

Mobilisation against AUKUS
The AUKUS announcement has unquestionably seen an increase in peace activism
amongst the Federation membership.

In 2023 on May Day, Federation members joined thousands of fellow workers across
the Illawarra in Port Kembla for a march and rally in opposition to AUKUS, the nuclear
submarine deal and Port Kembla as a possible site for a nuclear base.

In July the same year unionists and community leaders from Port Kembla attended
Federation’s Annual Conference as guests to hear a special report “On Peace”,
including from this inquiry’s lead commissioner, Peter Garrett. Conference noted that it
appeared that the weapons industry had been emboldened by the AUKUS decision and
called for their attempts to push their way into public schools, TAFE and universities to
be rejected.

Recommendations

Federation strongly believes that AUKUS deal must be scrapped by the Australian
government.

Notwithstanding this position, there are immediate answers the Albanese government
must provide the Australian people with regards to AUKUS – and they must be treated
as essential transparency obligations with respect to safety and costs.

Until there is clarity on the safety for communities with hosting nuclear submarines in
Australia, building nuclear submarines here and disposing of the highly enriched
uranium they will be built with, Federation cannot support AUKUS, and we call on both
the NSW and Australian government to immediately and categorically rule out a nuclear
submarine base at either Port Kembla or Newcastle.

Of equal importance is that the Albanese government stop hiding behind claims of every
detail being “classified”, and immediately provide the public with transparency around
the costs and the “deliverables” under the AUKUS agreement. When public schools still
have not reached the School Resourcing Standard and will not do so for at least
another 10 years, capital spending on public school infrastructure is all but absent,
TAFE colleges are trying to skill the future with outdated equipment that doesn’t meet
industry standards, and governments do not yet recognise and fund programs for
affordable home ownership for teachers in the public system, the least the Albanese government can do is provide details on exactly what this agreement is, including what
options Australia has if deliverables are not met by one or both of our AUKUS partners.


.

November 15, 2026 Posted by | Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Submission to AUKUS Public Inquiry -Australia should quit alliance with the UK and US – Dr Gideon Maxwell Polya.

No.258

“……………………My submission is in 3 parts and summarizes several detailed articles that set out why
Australia should quit alliance with the UK and US.

(A). As a UK lackey, US lackey or major climate criminal country Australia has
violated all circa 80 Indo-Pacific countries.

In 2021 Australia formed the anti-China AUKUS (Australia, UK and US) Alliance and
thence the Quad (Australia, India, US and Japan) Alliance to contain a supposedly
aggressive China. In reality as a nuclear terrorist, climate criminal, serial invader
and subversive entity Australia has violated all Indo-Pacific countries (see Gideon
Polya, “AUKUS & Quad In Context: Australia Violates All Indo-Pacific countries”,
Countercurrents, 9 December 2021: https://countercurrents.org/2021/12/aukus-qu
ad-in-context-australia-violates-all-indo-pacific-countries/ and for an exhaustively
referenced version see Gideon Polya, “Australia violates all Indo-Pacific countries”,
Stop state terrorism, 9 December 2021: https://sites.google.com/site/stopstateterr
orism/2021-12-09-australia-violates-all-indo-pacific-countries ).

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

………………………………………As a UK and thence US lackey, Australia in the last 80 years (i.e. WW2 onwards)
has had armed forces in many countries of the Indo-Pacific region, and has joined
the US in massive invasions and occupations. Australia has participated in all
post-1950 US Asian Wars (atrocities in which 40 million Asians have died from
violence and war-imposed deprivation). Anti-Arab anti-Semitic Australia has been
an enthusiastic participant in the US War on Terror (over 30 million Muslims have
died from violence and imposed deprivation in 20 countries invaded by the US
Alliance since the US Government-exploited 9/11 atrocity that killed 3,000 people).
The joint US-Australian telecommunications spying base at Pine Gap in Central
Australia targets war criminal US drone strikes on 7 Muslim countries.

As US lackeys Australians have been involved with the US in covert subversion of
many Indo-Pacific countries, and were successful in achieving regime change in 8
instances, namely Laos (1960), Indonesia (1965), Cambodia (1970), Chile (1973),
Australia (1975), Fiji (1987), Fiji (2000), and Australia (2010) (the latter 3 also
involving Apartheid Israel). Australia is second only to the US as a fervent
supporter of nuclear terrorist, genocidally racist, grossly human rights-abusing and
globally subversive Apartheid Israel, and hence of the utterly vile and intolerable
crime of Apartheid…………………………………………………………………………………………………

(B). Why Australia should quit military links with serial war criminal, genocidally
racist and egregiously mendacious America.

For a detailed and exhaustively referenced analysis see Gideon Polya, “Why
Australia Should Quit Military Links With Serial War Criminal America”,
Countercurrents, 28 January 2023: https://countercurrents.org/2023/01/why-austr
alia-should-quit-military-links-with-serial-war-criminal-america/ . Summarized
below are cogent arguments why Australia should quit its AUKUS alliance with
nuclear terrorist, genocidally racist and serial war criminal America and the UK.

(1). War typically violates International law, and is the penultimate in repugnant
racism, with genocide being the ultimate in racism…………………………………………..

(2). The US is a horrendous serial invader of other countries. Apart from inevitable
border spats, most countries in the world have not invaded other countries…………………………………………………

(3). War criminal active and passive mass murder by nuclear terrorist America and
the US Alliance. Iraq and Afghanistan were not the only countries murderously
violated by the US in the 21st century. It was estimated in 2015 that 32 million
Muslims had died from violence (5 million) and imposed deprivation (27 million) in
20 countries invaded by the US Alliance after the US Government-exploited 9/11
atrocity that killed 3,000 people, mostly innocent Americans…………………………………………………

(4) American lying ………………………… As cogently analysed by
Professors Edward Herman and Noam Chomsky in “Manufacturing Consent”,
mendacious US Mainstream media serve the interests of the US Establishment and
US governments.

(5). America violates, subverts, dirties and acutely threatens Australia.
(i). Australia was involved in all post-1950 US Asian wars.
(ii). AUKUS and Australian violation of all Indo-Pacific countries.
(iii). Australian involvement in 8 US-effected coups.
(iv). US lackey Australia’s deadly covert operations in neighbouring Indonesia.
(v). The US Murdoch media empire dominates Australia.
(vi). America spies on, subverts, deceives and betrays Australia.
(vii). UK- , US-, and Zionist-backed coups and other subversive interventions in
Australia.
(viii). Craven submission to American militarism makes Australia complicit in
nuclear terrorism and makes Australia a prime nuclear target.
(ix). Zionist subversion of IHRA member Australia is a product of blind Australian
fealty to Zionist-subverted America and soils Australia.

(x). Locked-in support for US militarism and militarist fiscal perversion inescapably
contributes to 100,000 preventable Australian deaths annually.

(xi). Australia is complicit in horrendous UK and US war crimes, notably in Iraq and
Afghanistan.
(xii). Blind support for the US has created a contemptible, reality-ignoring,
“look-the-other-way” Australian national culture.
(xiii). US lies and terror hysteria impacting Australian civil liberties.
(xiv). Genocidal US, US Alliance and Australia need de-Nazification.
(C). The AUKUS Alliance betrays, robs, soils, threatens and kills Australians.

………………………………… (i). AUKUS betrays Australians. The AUKUS deal supposedly protects Australian
sovereignty but the opposite is true. The nuclear submarines (if delivered) would
become Australia-crewed adjuncts to the naval strategy of a serial war-making US.
The deal locks an impotent Australia into US war-making strategy against our
biggest trading partner, China. Conversely, military strategy expert Albert Palazzo
(“The Big Fix”) argues that middle-power Australia should revert from a US-led
“strategic offensive” position to an efficient, effective and Australia-first “strategic
defensive” position. Our AUKUS partner, Zionist-perverted America, gets Australia
to hugely subsidize US war industry, makes Australia a prime nuclear target, and
substitutes hugely expensive, submarine hunting , White Elephant “sitting ducks”
for an intelligent, multi-faceted and high technology defence system.

(ii). AUKUS robs Australians. The Australia Institute estimates that the cost could
be $500 billion for a few second-hand, US-controlled, US-assisting, single-purpose
submarines that may already be detectable and vulnerable to the latest
AI-assisted anti-submarine technology. The US war industry gets A$500 billion and
in return Australia becomes a prime nuclear target, and gets locked into an absurd
“strategic offensive” position for the benefit of the US instead of an expert-advised
“strategic defensive” position for the defence of Australia.

(iii). AUKUS soils Australia. Racism is vile because to whom we are born and by
whom we are raised is out of our control. War is the penultimate in racism and
genocide the ultimate. The UK has invaded 193 countries or nearly every country.
Only 3 countries have not had a US military presence. Before WW2 the British
committed genocide on all inhabited continents whereas the US (African slavery
and Pacific islands aside) largely confined itself to the American Indian genocide
and domination of Latin America. After WW2 the UK replaced colonialism with
deadly neo-colonialism but also participated in the (deaths from violence and
deprivation in brackets) Palestinian (3 million), Korean (5 million), Iraqi (5 million), Libyan (0.2 million) and Afghan (7 million) Genocides. The US invaded a swathe of
countries around the world after WW2…………………………………………………………………….

(iv). AUKUS threatens Australians. The Australia-US joint spying base at Pine Gap,
Central Australia, plays a key role US nuclear terrorism and in targeting US and
Israeli bombing. Australia is constructing a huge base for nuclear-armed US
submarines in Western Australia, is expanding the Tindal air base in the Northern
Territory to host potentially nuclear-armed B-52 bombers, and hosts a
3,000-personnel US Marine base near Darwin. AUKUS makes Australia a prime
nuclear target – in any escalating nuclear war key bases in Australia and Australian
cities would be bombed before bombing any US cities………………………………………………….

(v). AUKUS will kill Australians. AUKUS will remove $500 billion from Australia’s
capacity to keep Australians alive and healthy via its prosperous economy-based
world-leading universal health care system, the National Disability Insurance
Scheme (NDIS), the education system, and preventive medicine…………………………………………………………. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1s1_Y3ywvk8ywqTLFvhOt3RfBFZfYH25g/view


November 15, 2026 Posted by | TOPICS | Leave a comment

Data centres revive Coalition passion for nuclear power, but this time more expensive and even less realistic

SMRs are “the most expensive form of energy you could possibly choose”

Peter Hannam, 12 November 2026, https://reneweconomy.com.au/data-centres-revive-coalition-passion-for-nuclear-power-but-this-time-more-expensive-and-even-less-realistic/amp/

The data centre-driven revival of the nuclear power debate in Australia is yet another political distraction from the urgent task of rapidly decarbonising the energy system, a new report has warned, only this time it’s focused on a technology that doesn’t technically exist: small modular reactors.

Small modular reactors (SMRs) aren’t operating commercially anywhere in the world despite decades of research and hype, won’t sate data centres’ energy hunger, and will dash federal Coalition hopes for an alternative to renewable energy, the report by the Australian Conservation Foundation (ACF) finds.

The Phantom Energy report, released on Thursday, details the lack of progress of SMRs globally.

“Nuclear power is too slow, too expensive, too unpopular, too dangerous and too thirsty to be a viable source of power for data centres in Australia,” the report says.

This has not stopped major technology firms such as Microsoft, Google, Amazon and Meta, from announcing nuclear energy partnerships to support growing data-centre demand, including inking more than a dozen agreements worth nearly 10 gigawatts (GW) of capacity.

“However, these commitments are largely non-binding agreements, power-purchase arrangements, or modest investments in SMR developers rather than direct funding for reactor construction,” report author Jim Green argues.

In particular, the US – home to those tech giants – has no SMRs or even large-scale reactors under construction. Plans to restart three shuttered reactors to power data centres “face obstacles and delays and only represent a tiny percent of electricity demand for data centres,” the report says.

Indeed, it cites a report by the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists from July that found nuclear funding commitments from Amazon and Google to be fraction of 1% of their annual expenditures earmarked for building data centres.

The spending was “primarily meant as greenwashing, in order to divert attention from the negative environmental impacts of data centre operations,” including much larger fossil fuel investments, the bulletin found.

Debate over how to power Australia’s data centre boom has intensified, as communities wrestle with how another 225 planned or proposed centres can be accommodated by a grid already hosting about 165 of them.

On the one hand, Chris Bowen, the federal climate change and energy minister, is insisting they source and supply their own renewable energy, although Queensland and the Northern Territory are pushing for fossil-fuel carveouts.

The federal Coalition, however, is pushing for nuclear energy – reviving a stance that was widely rejected in the 2025 elections, costing them as many as 11 seats. Prohibitions would need to be overturned under federal law and in states, including Queensland, New South Wales and Victoria.

Matt Canavan, the Nationals leader even told ABC’s Insiders last weekend that he’d “welcome nuclear power here every day of the week”.

“I’d much prefer a nuclear power station next door to me than a 300-metre wind turbine,” he said.

Aside from the “theoretical” possibility of having SMRs – defined as having an electrical generating capacity of 300 megawatts or less – advocates have to explain how they would produce competitively priced power in the US, Australia, or elsewhere.

“Electricity from the Natrium and Xe-100 SMR designs would cost at least twice as much as electricity from large nuclear plants [in the US] and the cost of electricity from large nuclear plants is at least three times higher than from solar and wind,” the ACF report says.

No wonder, then, that a 2025 survey found 78% of US adults polled were somewhat or very concerned that new data centres would increase their power bills, it said. (The data centre issue also reportedly hurt Republicans – the US equivalent of the Coalition – in the recent mid-term elections.)

The annual GenCost report by CSIRO, meanwhile, has consistently underscored the high cost of nuclear energy – both large and small – as the ACF noted.

SMRs are “the most expensive form of energy you could possibly choose,” Mia Popper, a nuclear free campaigner at the Australian Conservation Foundation, told Renew Economy.

November 15, 2026 Posted by | technology | Leave a comment

Quiet but sweeping defence changes are yet another blow to our public trust

The Coalition and Labor will most likely be in lockstep for the latest defence changes, a bill that sailed through the last House sitting while attention was mostly on estimates. It changes 14 different acts of legislation, while giving public servants ministerial powers to override state, territory and, in some cases, federal, laws if an area has been declared necessary for “defence capabilities”.

The Coalition and Labor will most likely be in lockstep for the latest defence changes, a bill that sailed through the last House sitting while attention was mostly on estimates. It changes 14 different acts of legislation, while giving public servants ministerial powers to override state, territory and, in some cases, federal, laws if an area has been declared necessary for “defence capabilities”.

Amy Remeikis, Nov 11, 2026, https://www.thenewdaily.com.au/news/politics/australian-politics/2026/11/11/defence-legislation-public-trust

Peter Dutton is someone who “politicises everything”. He is “loose”. He “darkened his own brand” and chose to “punch down on vulnerable people”. He “played political games” with national security. He was someone who engaged in “casual falsehoods” with international relations and “gaslit” the Australian public.

So of course it makes total sense that the same people who levelled all those criticisms at Dutton would also reward him with a plum position on the Australian War Memorial Council.

Politics is mostly about compliance above competency, and playing the game matters more than public integrity. After all, it’s all nudge-nudge, wink-wink when you’re in the club, right?

To most members of the club, announcing Dutton as the latest board appointment (or Sussan Ley for that matter) is considered a flash in the pan. They’ll weather the criticism, which they’ll assume comes from the usual suspects, and also assume that most voters won’t notice or care, and then the cycle will move on.

What they never take into account is the cost to public trust. That every political appointment, usually of someone rejected by the Australian people, undermines what little faith people still have that their politics can be different.

It shouldn’t have to take collapse and repudiation to bring politicians back to the reasons they purport to have wanted to get into politics in the first place.

But that seems to be what Labor is racing towards. And it is not just appointments that undermine this trust, but the hand-in-hand attack on civil liberties, like protest, and the ever-expanding security and defence state apparatus that continues to grow with almost no checks or balances by the parliament.

The Coalition and Labor will most likely be in lockstep for the latest defence changes, a bill that sailed through the last House sitting while attention was mostly on estimates. It changes 14 different acts of legislation, while giving public servants ministerial powers to override state, territory and, in some cases, federal, laws if an area has been declared necessary for “defence capabilities”.

What laws? We don’t know. That’s not in the bill. But if the minister of the time thinks an area needs to be designated as a defence zone, then the bill allows for public and private-owned assets, the land, sea and sky around it, to become no-go areas.

And another fun fact – you can’t appeal a decision. It sits above the law. So, no doubt, this will end up in the High Court at some point, when civil rights and policy experts get a chance to actually examine the legislation.

Canberra Times journalist Dave Allen is among those who reported on the bill early, while Rita Jabri Markwell, a lawyer, policy analyst and human rights scholar has updated on the bill’s capabilities on her Substack. Sydney Criminal Lawyers, one of the best outlets to follow for the decay of civil liberties, has also alerted on the legislation.

Mostly, though, the bill is being treated like most of Australia’s national security and defence laws – a fait accompli, that both major parties support, and barely worth mentioning more widely.

Never mind that the legislation allows defence personnel, private defence contractors and arms and tech manufacturers from other countries to be given some of the same authorities previously reserved for Australian Defence Force personnel and public servants. Never mind that designated public servants within defence would be given the powers to override state and territory laws if the ADF wants.

Never mind that we are about to create federal militarised zones because our government appears to be preparing for war – and no one is really being told about it, or why they believe it necessary (could it be because Australia is handing over sovereignty to the US with AUKUS, including through establishing more American military bases on our shores, which is what makes us more of a target in the first place?!).

The explanatory memorandum says the bill is to update Australia’s strategic responses for a new era, and to protect against drone attacks. That’s on the minds of all Western powers after Iran showed it did not need multibillion-dollar aircraft carriers or navies to defend its territory – it managed it mostly through drones and AI Lego videos on social media.

The legislation changes will allow defence officials, ratified by the minister (a tick and flick exercise, at best), to declare special security zones, even temporarily, where unauthorised entry or presence (so, protest) – among other unauthorised and restricted activities – could land you in jail and or heavily fined.

Police will be given powers to patrol these special zones, along with defence and defence security officials, who will be given special enforcement gear by Defence for the purposes of their patrol.

Citizens can be searched, detained, compelled to show ID, subjected to use of force, including with dogs, and have items, including vehicles, boats or planes, seized.

It’s a bill the “Temu Trump” himself would have been proud to have under his authority.

So, of course, there will be no conservatives jumping up and down about property rights. No questions of overreach. Just another knock to Australian’s civil liberties that most won’t even know about. It should be more of a scandal that we are sold so cheaply.

Amy Remeikis is a contributing editor for The New Daily and chief political analyst for The Australia Institute

November 14, 2026 Posted by | weapons and war | Leave a comment

Artificial intelligence, nuclear power a costly combo

ByJennifer Dudley-Nicholson, November 12 2026, https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/9390176/artificial-intelligence-nuclear-power-a-costly-combo/

Powering Australia’s growing network of data centres with small nuclear reactors could cost between $6 billion and $11 billion more a year than using solar power, a study has found.

The technology could also take decades to deploy in Australia as no small modular reactors had been built successfully using a mass-production model.

The Australian Conservation Foundation issued the warnings on Thursday in a report examining the nuclear technology and its potential costs in Australia.

It comes days after Nationals leader Matt Canavan reiterated his call to remove Australia’s ban on nuclear power and as the federal government considers rules for data centre developments.

The report, Phantom Energy, analysed the progress of small modular reactor technology, data centre electricity demand in Australia, and figures from sources including the CSIRO, Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO), and the Nuclear Energy Agency.

Despite calls to unlock the technology, the study found no commercial reactors had been built using the modular manufacturing methods designed to lower their cost.

Only two small plants described as small modular reactors had been built in Russia and China, and both had suffered long delays, cost overruns, and did not use modular construction.

Another five small modular nuclear projects were under way in China, Russia, Uzbekistan and Canada, the report said, but others had been abandoned in Argentina, France and the US.

The nuclear technology was not ready to meet rising energy demand from data centres, Australian Conservation Foundation campaigner Mia Pepper said, and its future was unclear.

“Small modular nuclear reactors remain unavailable and prohibitively expensive,” she said.

“They remain a theoretical answer to a very real and rapidly growing challenge: decarbonising the electricity system while meeting increasing demand from electrification, industry, and data-intensive technologies.”

More than 160 data centres operate in Australia, with another 225 developments planned or proposed.

Using forecasts from the CSIRO and AEMO, the report calculated that powering Australia’s data centres using small modular reactors would cost between $8.5 billion and $12.2 billion a year.

By comparison, large-scale solar projects would cost between $780 million and $2 billion a year, and onshore wind developments would cost between $1.9 billion and $3.1 billion.

The federal government is considering rules for data centre developments, including standards for their power supply and water use, with draft legislation expected before the end of 2026.

In an interview with the ABC on Monday, however, Senator Canavan said the government should remove Australia’s prohibition on nuclear power to meet data centre demands.

“Right now while we ban nuclear energy, we have de facto bans on coal and gas, it’s almost impossible to meet the enormous requirements of data centres, certainly without giving people confidence that there can be more energy after than before,” he said.

November 14, 2026 Posted by | energy | Leave a comment

Phantom energy: New report exposes empty promises behind nuclear power and data centres

“Coalition and One Nation members pushing nuclear for data centres are ignoring the reality that small modular nuclear reactors don’t exist and there is no serious investment in SMRs for data centres anywhere in the world.

12 November 2026, https://www.acf.org.au/news/phantom-energy-new-report-exposes-empty-promises-behind-nuclear-power-and-data-centres

The push for nuclear-powered data centres is entirely dependent on technology that remains commercially unproven and prohibitively expensive, according to a new report released today by the Australian Conservation Foundation.

Several Coalition shadow ministers are promoting nuclear power, particularly small modular nuclear reactors, or SMRs, as a potential energy source for data centres.

Shadow energy minister Dan Tehan, Nationals leader Matt Canavan, Nationals deputy Bridget McKenzie, shadow minister Andrew Hastie and Liberal senator Jonno Duniam have all said nuclear power should play a role in supplying electricity to data centres.

“SMRs are presented as a solution to Australia’s future energy needs, but they remain a theoretical answer to a very real and rapidly growing challenge: decarbonising the electricity system while meeting increasing demand from electrification, industry and data-intensive technologies,” said ACF’s nuclear free campaigner Mia Pepper.

“Australia has more than 160 operating data centres and many more are planned.

“The rapid spread of data centres – including proposals to power them with coal and gas – has sparked serious and widespread concerns about energy, water and land use, health impacts, electricity prices and the growth of AI.

“The International Energy Agency expects renewables to provide around two-thirds of new electricity generation for data centres between 2024 and 2035, compared with just 6% from nuclear – and much of that projected nuclear contribution relies on SMRs suddenly becoming commercially viable.

“Small modular nuclear reactors remain unavailable and prohibitively expensive. There is a growing list of abandoned attempts to build prototypes globally.

“Coalition and One Nation members pushing nuclear for data centres are ignoring the reality that small modular nuclear reactors don’t exist and there is no serious investment in SMRs for data centres anywhere in the world.

“The push for nuclear-powered data centres risks distracting – possibly deliberately – from the urgent task of rapidly decarbonising Australia’s energy system.

“Combining two of the most unpopular industries, data centres and nuclear power, is a strange political strategy to win over a public that staunchly opposes both.”

Read the report: Phantom energy: Small modular reactors and data centres

November 13, 2026 Posted by | technology | Leave a comment

Public Inquiry into AUKUS recommends recalibrating Australia’s relationship with the US

November 5, 2026, https://australiainstitute.org.au/post/public-inquiry-into-aukus-recommends-recalibrating-australias-relationship-with-the-us/

The four-month AUKUS public inquiry has recommended a recalibration of Australia’s relationships with the United States and China, including the cancellation of nuclear-powered submarines.

The launch of the commissioners’ final report, Surrendering Australia – The AUKUS Deception, coincided with US mid-term elections that significantly reshaped the American political landscape.

“Yesterday, the people of the US recalibrated their relationship with the US government, rejecting the policies of President Trump.  Now is the perfect time for Australia to do the same,” said Leanne Minshull, co-CEO of The Australia Institute and one of five public inquiry commissioners.

Recent polling conducted on behalf of The Australia Institute found just 16% of Australian voters now consider the US to be a ‘close friend’ of Australia.

The AUKUS deal is sending hundreds of billions of dollars overseas but it also has a clear way out, the first step being to give the US and UK one year’s notice of withdrawal.

“In a cost-of-living crisis, redirecting hundreds of billions of dollars allocated to AUKUS would not just boost our national security but our economic security as well.”

The full Commissioners’ Report can be found here

November 10, 2026 Posted by | politics international | Leave a comment