Australian govt rejects a report that recommends nuclear submarines
French submarine program ‘dangerously off track’ warns report urging Australia to consider nuclear alternative, ABC News, By defence correspondent Andrew Greene 11 Mar, 20 Australia’s $80 billion Future Submarine Program is “dangerously off track” according to a new report that urges the Government to ditch the controversial project and consider a nuclear option.
Key points:
- The report indicates there are fears the current project is at a high risk of failing
- The Defence Minister denies those fears and maintains the project remains on track
- Under a proposed “Plan B” scenario, the company that designed the Collins class submarines would prepare an updated design
Businessman Gary Johnston, who commissioned and funded the study, fears the current plan to build 12 attack class submarines designed by French company Naval Group is at “high risk” of failing.
His report, prepared by Insight Economics, suggests Australia should instead immediately begin work on a “Plan B” — an evolved version of the current Collins class fleet — before eventually acquiring nuclear-powered boats.
Earlier this year, a report from the auditor-general confirmed the Future Submarine Program was running nine months late and Defence was unable to show whether the $396 million spent so far had been “fully effective”.
“The Government’s own advisory body, including three American admirals, even recommended the Government should consider walking away from the project,” Mr Johnston said.
Under the proposed “Plan B”, Swedish company Saab Kockums, which designed the navy’s Collins class submarines, would be asked to prepare an updated design for the future submarine fleet.
In 2022-23, both Naval Group and Saab will present their competing preliminary design studies for building the first batch of three submarines in Adelaide — based on a fixed price, capability, delivery and local content.
Mr Johnston, along with former naval officers in the Submarines for Australia organisation, argue that over the long term the Government should begin preparing to acquire nuclear submarines……
Government rejects report, issues warning
The Submarines for Australia report will be formally launched by ANU Emeritus Professor Hugh White at the National Press Club today, but it is already drawing fire from the Morrison Government.
“I totally reject the premise that this project is ‘dangerously off track’, as stated in the new Submarines for Australia report”, Defence Minister Linda Reynolds said.
“The delivery of the attack class submarine remains on track, with construction set to commence in 2023.”
Senator Reynolds said the technical feasibility of delivering an evolved Collins class submarine was reviewed in 2013-14, but a review found it would be equivalent to a whole new design, involving similar costs and risks, without a commensurate gain in capability.
“This assessment by Submarines for Australia will only increase cost, delay the delivery, and put at risk our submarine capability.”
The Defence Minister also flatly rejected any suggestion of a nuclear-powered submarine in the future.
“As has been the policy of successive Australian Governments, a nuclear-powered submarine is not being considered as an option for the attack class submarine,” Senator Reynolds said.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-03-11/australia-urged-to-embrace-nuclear-submarines/12043444
AEMC approves Victoria’s request to go it alone on energy reliability reform — RenewEconomy
AEMC approves request from Victoria for ‘enhanced RERT’ powers to allow AEMO to secure multi-year emergency electricity supply contracts. The post AEMC approves Victoria’s request to go it alone on energy reliability reform appeared first on RenewEconomy.
via AEMC approves Victoria’s request to go it alone on energy reliability reform — RenewEconomy
March 11 Energy News — geoharvey
Opinion: ¶ “Why Russia And Vladimir Putin Are Waging An Oil War With America” • Vladimir Putin knows America’s fragile oil industry is built on a mountain of debt. Moscow’s refusal to join with OPEC to mitigate oversupply is aimed in part at drowning US shale oil companies, which compete with Russian oil but rely […]
Japan may have to cancel the Olympics — Fukushima 311 Watchdogs
Covid-19 could scupper Prime Minister Abe Shinzo’s pet project March 7, 2020 IF BANYAN HAD to choose one country in which to ride out a pandemic, it would surely be Japan. Early 19th-century woodblock prints of bathing testify to Japan’s old and admirable cult of cleanliness. Modern Japanese have for years been quick to […]
via Japan may have to cancel the Olympics — Fukushima 311 Watchdogs
Regional community solar and storage projects win NSW government grants — RenewEconomy
NSW government awards seven grants to community solar and storage projects across regional parts of the state. The post Regional community solar and storage projects win NSW government grants appeared first on RenewEconomy.
via Regional community solar and storage projects win NSW government grants — RenewEconomy
Rooftop solar unstoppable as market breaks “all previous records” in February — RenewEconomy
Australia’s rooftop solar market has shown no signs of slowing down so far in 2020, with booming residential installations in February helping to break all previous records and delivering the highest monthly registered capacity of 218MW. The post Rooftop solar unstoppable as market breaks “all previous records” in February appeared first on RenewEconomy.
via Rooftop solar unstoppable as market breaks “all previous records” in February — RenewEconomy
Japan begins solar powered hydrogen production at Fukushima plant — RenewEconomy
FH2R project completed at former nuclear hub, able to produce “green” hydrogen powered by a 20MW solar farm and some grid power. The post Japan begins solar powered hydrogen production at Fukushima plant appeared first on RenewEconomy.
via Japan begins solar powered hydrogen production at Fukushima plant — RenewEconomy
Australian researchers smash efficiency record for ‘tandem solar cells’ — RenewEconomy
ANU research team use tandem solar cell technology to achieve a conversion efficiency of 27.7% and are aiming to go above 30% for their next goal. The post Australian researchers smash efficiency record for ‘tandem solar cells’ appeared first on RenewEconomy.
via Australian researchers smash efficiency record for ‘tandem solar cells’ — RenewEconomy
Antinuclear 