Witnesses recommended for the next Citizens’ Jury on Nuclear Waste Importing, South Australia
This is a full list of witnesses chosen by the Nuclear Citizens’ Jury on October 9th and invited to be witnesses for the next Nuclear Citizens’ Jury on 29 October.
Here I have endeavoured to shed light on the likely evidence of each, according to the following code :
GREEN = Anti-nuclear waste dumping , Yellow – doubtful on waste importing. ORANGE=Neutral – Uncertain, about waste dumping, BLACK = I don’t know, PINK = probably pro waste dumping , RED = Pro nuclear waste dumping
- I ran into a spot of bother with the many Aboriginals recommended. As far as I can tell, they are all opposed to importing nuclear waste, except Parry Agius . Some of the most prominent Aboriginal persons are: Kevin Buzzacott, Karina Lester, Rose Lester, Vivienne McKenzie, Enice Marsh.
- Some pro nuclear people might be opposed to the dump plan, so I put those in pink.
Nuclear Citizens Jury Two: Witness work
WITNESSES CHOSEN BY JURY AND INVITED FOR THE 29th
No List Ref Name Votes Theme
1 123 Richard Dennis 96 Economics
2 121 Professor Richard Blandy 54 Economics
3 128 Professor Barbara Pocock 45 Economics
4 179 Professor Brian Cox 45 Safety
5 166 Hon Nick Xenophon 44 Trust
6 56 Paddy Crumlin 34 Safety
7 1 Timo Aikas 34 Safety
8 4 Professor Rodney Ewing 31 Safety
9 168 Dr Karl Kruszelnicki 30 Safety
10 116 Dr Simon Longstaff 29 Trust
11 5 Robert J Halstead 27 Safety
12 19 Dr Jim Green 25 Safety
13 9 Dr Carl Magnus‐Larsson 25 Safety
14 162 Ian Hore‐Lacy 22 Economics
15 49 Professor Tilman Ruff, AM 22 Safety
16 53 Frank Boulton 21 Safety
17 188 Someone from the Attorney Generals Department to provide advice on the legislation that will be required to be developed/changed. DemocracyCo seeking advice on who. Trust
18 124 Assoc. Professor Mark Diesendorf 20 Economics
19 7 Dr Andrew Herczeg 20 Safety
20 42 Dr Ian Fairlie 19 Safety
21 137 Hon Mark Parnell, MLC 18 Economics
22 39 Dr Margaret Beavis 18 Safety
23 119 Assoc. Professor Haydon Manning 17 Trust
24 122 John Carlson AM 16 Economics
25 200 Dr Benito Cao 16 Economics
26 18 Professor David Giles 16 Safety
27 115 Steven McIntosh 16 Trust
28 2 Dr Ian Chessell 14 Safety
29 34 Professor Sandy Steacy 14 Safety
30 69 Gill McFadyen 11 Consent
31 74 Dave Sweeney 10 Consent
32 104 Bob Watts 9 Consent
33 76 Ross Womersley 8 Consent
34 72 Dr Gerald Ouzounian 7 Consent
35 73 Dan Spencer 6 Consent
36 126 Tim Johnson 7 Economics Invited to provide info on the Royal Commission economic modelling after 20+ requests on Information Gap Cards Dotmocracy Results ‐ 25 plus a few extras to allow for availability Top 6 from Consent ‐ as Gill is unavailable.
Nuclear Citizens Jury Two: Witness work
ABORIGINAL WITNESSES ALREADY INVITED ON THE 29TH
Ref No Name Votes Topic
77 Marilyn Ah Chee Aborigional Consent
78 Peter Buckskin Aboriginal Consent
79 Kevin Buzzacott Aboriginal Consent
80 Dr Scott Cane Aboriginal Consent
81 Andrew Collett AM Aboriginal Consent
82 Terrence Coulthard Aboriginal Consent
83 Ian Crombie Aboriginal Consent
84 Eddie Fry Aboriginal Consent
85 Murray George Aboriginal Consent
86 Jeremy LeBois Aboriginal Consent
87 Karina Lester Aboriginal Consent
88 Rose Lester Aboriginal Consent
89 Vivienne McKenzie Aboriginal Consent
90 Enice Marsh Aboriginal Consent
91 Wanda Miller Aboriginal Consent
92 Jeffrey Newchurch Aboriginal Consent
93 Shirley Peisley, AM Aboriginal Consent
94 Keith Peters Aboriginal Consent
95 Clyde Rigney Aboriginal Consent
96 Grant Rigney Aboriginal Consent
97 Tauto Sansbury Aboriginal Consent
98 Aaron Stuart Aboriginal Consent
99 Mima Smart Aboriginal Consent
101 Jared Thomas Aboriginal Consent
102 Keith Thomas Aboriginal Consent
103 Simone Ulalka Tur Aboriginal Consent
104 Barbara Wingard Aboriginal Consent
105 Glen Wingfield Aboriginal Consent
Nuclear Citizens Jury Two: Witness work
ABORIGINAL NGO’S INVITED ‐ AT THE SUGGESTION OF ADVISORY BOARD
Name Organisation
Louise Herft Aboriginal Aged Rights Advocacy
Mia and Ivan Copley Aboriginal Centre For Information and Arts in SA Inc
Scott Wilson Aboriginal Drug and Alcohol Council (SA) Inc
Jennifer Wissell Aboriginal Elders Village
Sharron Williams Aboriginal Family Support Services Inc
Graham Aitken Aboriginal Home Care
Sheryl Axleby Aboriginal Legal Rights Movement Inc
Bob Pitson Aboriginal Prisoners and Offenders Support Services
Joe Silvestri Aboriginal Sobriety Group (ASG)
Bruce Underwood Anangu Tertiary Education Program (ANTEP)
Garth Dodd Council For Aboriginal Elders of South Australia
Lorraine Connor David Unaipon College of Indigenous Education and Research
Jillian Miller Indigenous Student Services
Basil Coleman Kumangka Aboriginal Youth Service
Tina Quitadamo Kura Yerlo Centre Inc
Sharen Letton Metropolital Aboriginal Youth and Family Services (MAYFS)
Fredrick Kelly Neporendi Aboriginal Forum
John Singer Nganampa Health Council Inc
Carol Varley Nunkuwarrin Yunti Inc
Louise Turner SA Link‐UP
Keith Thomas South Australian Native Title Services (SANTS)
Jo Leonello State Aboriginal Women’s Gathering (and working group)
Timothy Ritchie Tandanya National Aboriginal Cultural Institute
Doug Milera Tauondi Aboriginal College
Michelle Merrick Western Aboriginal Specific Homelessness Service
Lyn Niemz Wodli HOME Advice Program
Esther Blewit Yunggorendi First Nations Centre for Higher Education and Res
Lisa Hanson (Agius) Office of Indigenous Strategy and Engagement ‐ Flinders Unive
Sir/Madam Aboriginal Elders and Community Care Services Inc
Sir/Madam Nunkuwarrin Yunti of South Australia
Sir/Madam Aboriginal Ministries in Outback South Australia
Sir/Madam Congress of Aboriginal Community Development & Education
Sir/Madam Grannies Group
Sir/Madam Aboriginal Business Industry Chamber of South Australia
3
Nuclear Citizens Jury Two: Witness work
OTHER WITNESSES ‐ DOTMOCRACY RESULTS
No List Ref Name Votes Theme
37 10 Dr Mark Nutt N/A Safety
38 20 Janine Herzig N/A Safety
39 17 Dr Andreas Gautschi N/A Safety
40 35 Professor the Hon Gareth Evans N/A Safety
41 71 Professor Ian Olver N/A Consent
42 151 Professor Derek Abbott 13 Economics
43 6 Dr Sami Hautakangas 13 Safety
44 15 Xavier Domingo 13 Safety
45 30 Michael Siemann 13 Safety
46 125 Chad Jacobi 12 Economics
47 3 Alun Ellis 12 Safety
48 21 Dr Steve Hill 12 Safety
49 54 Alastair Brown 12 Safety
50 186 A legal opinion/constitutional lawyer 12 Juror addition
51 191 Mohamed El‐Baradei 12 Juror addition
52 132 Professor Paul Kerin 11 Economics
53 23 Dr Charles McCombie 11 Safety
54 16 Ian Gault 11 Safety
55 33 Lissa Van Camp 11 Safety
56 69 Gill McFadyen 11 Consent
57 136 Nigel McBride 10 Economics
58 147 Peter Joy 10 Economics
59 143 Craig Wilkins 10 Economics
60 27 Kyra Reznikov 10 Safety
61 74 Dave Sweeney 10 Consent
62 118 Hon Scott Ludlam 9 Trust
63 13 Wayne Cowley 9 Safety
64 62 Dr Mike Weightman 9 Safety
65 37 Professor Andrew O’Neil 9 Safety
66 104 Bob Watts 9 Consent
67 177 Nuclear Waste Agency Japan, Korea, or T 9 Juror addition
68 194 Dan Gilchrist or Rod Campbell Aust.Inst 9 Juror addition
69 196 Erin Brockovich 9 Juror addition
70 197 Roman Orszanki 9 Juror addition
71 153 Dr David LeBlanc 8 Economics
72 65 Melissa Ballantyne 8 Safety
73 44 Dr Tony Hooker 8 Safety
74 76 Ross Womersley 8 Consent
75 161 Wolf Blass 8 Juror addition
76 176 Greg Hall 8 Juror addition
77 201 Hon Sarah Hanson‐Young 8 Juror addition
78 131 William D’Haesler 7 Economics
79 134 The Hon Rob Lucas 7 Economics
80 148 Rob Kerin 7 Economics
81 158 Dr Adrian Paterson 7 Economics
82 52 Professor Geraldine Thomas 7 Safety
83 72 Dr Gerald Ouzanian 7 Consent
84 164 Gabrielle Kelly 7 Juror addition
85 174 David Jepsen 7 Juror addition
86 133 Mr David Knox 6 Economics
87 146 Dr Freya Higgins ‐ Desbiolles 6 Economics
88 25 Dr Dirk Mallants 6 Safety
89 12 Jim Conca 6 Safety
90 73 Dan Spencer 6 Consent
91 181 Ally Fricker 6 Juror addition
Nuclear Citizens Jury Two: Witness work
92 187 Someone who knows about current law 6 Juror addition
93 114 John Loy 5 Trust
94 157 Professor Jean Palutikof 5 Economics
95 24 Dr Arjun Makhijani 5 Safety
96 68 Pro Hank Jenkins‐Smith 5 Consent
97 68 Professor Hank Jenkins Smith 5 Consent
98 173 Rep from SA Tourism Commission 5 Juror addition
99 178 Dan Monceaux 5 Juror addition
100 127 Dr Julian Morison 4 Economics
101 139 Dr Jim Stanford 4 Economics
102 149 Professor Goran Roos 4 Economics
103 144 Professor Mike Young 4 Economics
104 156 Dr Sven Teske 4 Economics
105 154 Dr Eric Loewen 4 Economics
106 152 Ben Heard 4 Economics
107 160 Robert Parker 4 Economics
108 64 Keith Baldry 4 Safety
109 14 Paul Degnan 4 Safety
110 11 Rebecca Stohr 4 Safety
111 43 Dr Robert Hall 4 Safety
112 38 Sam Roggeveen 4 Safety
113 32 Paul Standring 4 Safety
114 167 Executive Officer Centre of Ethics and Te 4 Juror addition
115 171 Statistician, expert mult‐factor risk asses 4 Juror addition
116 138 Geoffrey Rothwell 3 Economics
117 150 Darren Thomas 3 Economics
118 159 Joe Szakacs 3 Economics
119 155 Amory Lovins 3 Economics
120 8 Paul Howe 3 Safety
121 63 Steve Green 3 Safety
122 61 Mark Jervis 3 Safety
123 60 Don Hancock 3 Safety
124 58 Quentin Flowers 3 Safety
125 57 Jack Dillich 3 Safety
126 51 Professor Pam Sykes 3 Safety
127 46 Professor Dorothy Keefe 3 Safety
128 45 Mary Houlahan 3 Safety
129 40 Professor Eva Bezak 3 Safety
130 36 Dr Ed Lyman 3 Safety
131 63 Steve Green 3 Safety
132 67 Patrick Davoren 3 Consent
133 170 Young person from youth forum 3 Juror addition
134 189 Dean Firgie or Michael Kirby 3 Juror addition
135 192 Mayor of Port August or Whyalla or rep. 3 Juror addition
136 195 Dr Mike Sandiford 3 Juror addition
137 204 Parry Agius/John Mansfield 3 Juror addition
138 129 Dr Leanna Read 2 Economics
139 135 Mr Brendan Lyon 2 Economics
140 142 Steve Whetton 2 Economics
141 140 James Voss 2 Economics
142 28 Paul Roberts 2 Safety
143 26 Neil Power 2 Safety
144 22 Jason Kuchel 2 Safety
145 59 Hefin Griffiths 2 Safety
146 48 Professor Daniel Roos 2 Safety
147 66 Anne Bainbridge 2 Consent
148 109 Dr John Read 2 Consent
149 111 Mark Sutton 2 Consent
5
Nuclear Citizens Jury Two: Witness work
150 169 Elle McNamara 2 Juror addition
151 182 A young person who can talk on consent 2 Juror addition
152 190 Minister Koutsantonis/Dan Van Holst Pe 2 Juror addition
153 203 Helen Williams/JoFord 2 Juror addition
154 120 Richard Yeeles 1 Trust
155 55 Professor Neil Chapman 1 Safety
156 47 Assoc Professor Michael Penniment 1 Safety
157 41 Adj Assoc Professor Elizabeth Dabars AM 1 Safety
158 31 Kris Singh 1 Safety
159 75 Dr Maarten van Geet 1 Consent
160 107 Dr Jen Cleary 1 Consent
161 108 Dr Jullian Marsh 1 Consent
162 110 Kelly‐ Anne Saffin 1 Consent
163 12 Cecilia Woolford 1 Consent
164 172 Systems thinker Sweden 1 Juror addition
165 184 Someone from Parliamentary Joint Comm 1 Juror addition
166 199 Cllr Lisa Lumsden 1 Juror addition
167 113 Felix Altorfer 0 Trust
168 117 Proessor Ian Lowe 0 Trust
169 130 Assoc. Professor John Spoehr 0 Economics
170 141 Greg Ward 0 Economics
171 145 Jo Collins 0 Economics
172 29 Nima Sherpa 0 Safety
173 50 Dr Stephen Solomon 0 Safety
174 70 Jean‐Paul Minon 0 Consent
175 67 Patrick Davoren 0 Consent
176 70 Jean‐Paul Minon 0 Consent
177 77‐106 Aboriginal Witness Program (except
104 Bob Watts) Consent
178 165 Martin Seligman Juror addition
179 175 Keith Baverstock Juror addition
180 183 Deidre Palmer Juror addition
181 193 Person speak to clean, green production eg Jurli Juror addition
182 198 Lucas Heights (ANSTO) Senior Exec in nuclear safJuror addition
6
1 Comment »
Leave a Reply
1.This month.
The Road to War brings a sharp focus to why it is not in Australia’s best interest to be dragged into a war with China which will almost inevitably go nuclear very quickly. The filmmaker has interviewed some of Australia’s senior foreign policy analysts who have vast experience behind them in analysing what really is going on here as the United States rattles its sabres with China. And sets us up to be its proxy, like the poor Ukranians have been fed into the Meatgrinder. So America can remain the Top Dog. The Road to War reveals how the United States through its spy base at Pine Gap and by stationing six nuclear capable B52 bombers in the Top End (without permission from the traditional owners) is making Australia a prime nuclear target if the current war of words suddenly melts down into full scale war.
The Road to War shows the implicit connection between Carbon emissions (the US military uses a whopping 70% of America’s annual petroleum to move its armies and vast War Machine around the globe to its 800+ military bases..but under a loophole wangled at Kyoto, the US military does not have to report its C02 annual emissions). The Road to War starts screening at selected cities and regional centres in March. See the trailer end for details.
Antinuclear 
9 Dr Karl – probably pro-nuke
23 Haydon Manning – definitely pro-nuke (Political Science, Flinders Uni)
154 Richard Yeeles – strongly pro-nuke (Former PR for BHP and Olympic Dam Project)
161 JILLIAN Marsh (Adnyamuthna)- Not JULLIAN
LikeLike