Antinuclear

Australian news, and some related international items

The AUKUS Public Inquiry is not going to just fade away

16 November 2026, Noel Wauchope

The repercussions of this Inquiry may take a while, but angst about AUKUS is something that is not confined to Australians – more on this, later.

Meanwhile, militarism continues to thrive, and our Prime Minister is busy in Manila, doing defence deals with the Philippines and Japan – because we all know that China is such a military threat to everyone.

And I have been pressing on, carefully reading another 60 of the 1028 Submissions to the Inquiry.
55 of these submissions clearly opposed AUKUS. Two were sort of neutral, and three were in favour of AUKUS.

In the arguments against AUKUS, once again, the main issue was the exorbitant cost. However, many submissions just focussed on the cost, without mentioning any alternative ways towards Australia’s security. So, the more convincing submissions were those that also dealt with the nuclear submarines themselves – as being unsuitable for Australia’s needs, or obsolete by the time we get them if we ever do. Some submissions went into detail on this, and on practical alternatives.

There were many powerful arguments about Australia’s loss of sovereignty, in becoming part of the USA’s military strategy. A Western Australian group writes:

The military interoperability and increased implementation of the Force Posture AgreementM(FPA) implicit in AUKUS will ensure further subservience to the USA, obliging Australia to continue following the US into wars of its choosing. The assumption that subservience to the US or having US bases on our soil will ensure Australia’s security and safety is false particularly in light of the prevailing “America First” agenda. The recent attacks on US Bases in West Asia are also testimony to this.

And many felt strongly that AUKUS will draw Australia into a USA war with China., and that China, our important trading partner, is not a threat to Australia.

Another passionate consideration was concern for democracy – the secretive, undemocratic way in which Australia’s decision on AUKUS came about:

The complete absence of meaningful community consultation regarding Australia’s entry into the AUKUS agreement is also deeply concerning, and is one of the reasons for this inquiry. Many members of the community feel powerless, alienated and angry by the lack of transparency surrounding such a significant and locked in costly national commitment. (Mothers for a Sustainable South Australia.)

The Mothers for a Sustainable South Australia reflected a particularly South Australian perspective on nuclear submarines:

South Australian Traditional Owners have consistently rejected proposals for nuclear waste facilities because of their lived experience with the devastating legacy of radioactive contamination. The historical trauma resulting from British nuclear weapons testing during the 1950s and 1960s – including displacement, illness and ongoing damage to Country – continues to affect communities today.

The experience of South Australia demonstrates that proposals involving nuclear waste have profound social, environmental and cultural consequences, particularly for First Nations peoples. Past failures in consultation and the enduring impacts of nuclear activities on Traditional Owners highlight the need for a transparent, inclusive and evidence-based decision-making process.

Submissions from South Australians were prominent, as were those from Stirling, Western Australia, and from the Port Kembla area in New South Wales, – all areas which are earmarked for nuclear submarine activities.

The need for Australia to have a defence strategy that suits its role in the region was a big topic of concern – a regional security strategy, rather than being a part of U.S militarism.

Many submissions were very concerned about transparency, and the failure of the Australian Parliament to scrutinise or debate AUKUS. Former Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull’s submission went into detail on this, as well as on the background and unsuitability of the planned nuclear submarines:

The Pillar I submarine acquisition, as currently structured, was created by the Morrison Government and adopted by the Albanese government. It is a bipartisan error; a submarine deal that will likely result in Australia not receiving any submarines at all.

It will certainly leave Australia with long gaps in submarine capability. The AUKUS bargain is thoroughly unfair to Australia. It makes Australia even more dependent on the United States as the US is becoming, by design, a less dependable ally.

There has been no comprehensive parliamentary inquiry into AUKUS Pillar I comparable in depth or rigour to the scrutiny applied by the United States Congress or the British House of Commons… This Inquiry, whatever its formal limitations, performs a function that Parliament should have.

Finally, I can’t help quoting from my favourite Submission – this one – We need a smart defence strategy, not the AUKUS fantasy – from Merrill Stokes:

The fact that this contract requires Australia to pay a very large sum of money even if we never take possession of the Virginia class submarines seems like something out of ‘Alice and Wonderland’ where reality has been turned on its head. That is not a contract; That is called tribute. We need to remember Kissinger’s statement that “to be an enemy of the United States is dangerous but to be a friend is fatal.”

November 18, 2026 - Posted by | Christina reviews

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply